Page 1
Passage 3 How should reading be taught?
1
SECTION 3
READING PASSAGE 3
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 27-40 which are based on Reading
Passage 3 below.
How should reading be taught?
By Keith Rayncr an Barbara R Foorman
A
Learning to speak is automatic for almost all children, but learning to read requires
elaborate instruction and conscious effort. Well aware of the difficulties, educators have
given a great deal of thought to how they can best help children learn to read. No single
method has triumphed. Indeed, heated arguments about the most appropriate form of
reading instruction continue to polarize the teaching community.
B
Three general approaches have been tried. In one, called whole-word instruction,
children learn by rote how to recognise at a glance a vocabulary of 50 to 100 words.
Then they gradually acquire other words, often through seeing them used over and over
again in the context of a story.
Speakers of most languages learn the relationship between letters and the sounds
associated with them (phonemes). That is, children are taught how to use their
knowledge of the alphabet to sound out words. This procedure constitutes a second
approach to teaching reading – phonics.
Many schools have adopted a different approach: the whole-language method. The
strategy here relies on the child’s experience with language. For example, students are
offered engaging books and are encouraged to guess the words that they do not know
by considering the context of the sentence or by looking for clues in the storyline and
illustrations, rather than trying to sound them out.
Many teachers adopted the whole-language approach because of its intuitive appeal.
Making reading fun promises to keep children motivated, and learning to read depends
more on what the student does than on what the teacher does. The presumed benefits
of whole-language instruction – and the contrast to the perceived dullness of phonics –
led to its growing acceptance across American during the 1990s, and a movement away
from phonics.
Page 2
Passage 3 How should reading be taught?
2
C
However, many linguists and psychologists objected strongly to the abandonment of
phonics in American schools. Why was this so? In short, because research had clearly
demonstrated that understanding how letters related to the component sounds in
words is critically important in reading. This conclusion rests, in part, on knowledge of
how experienced readers make sense of words on a page. Advocates of whole-language
instruction have argued forcefully that people often derive meanings directly from print
without ever determining the sound of the word. Some psychologists today accept this
view, but most believe that reading is typically a process of rapidly sounding out words
mentally. Compelling evidence for this comes from experiments which show that
subjects often confuse homophones (words that sound the same, such as Jrose and
‘rows’). This supports the idea that readers convert strings of letters to sounds.
D
In order to evaluate different approaches to teaching reading, a number of experiments
have been carried out, firstly with college students, then with school pupils.
Investigators trained English-speaking college students to read using unfamiliar symbols
such as Arabic letters (the phonics approach), while another group learned entire words
associated with certain strings of Arabic letters (whole-word). Then both groups were
required to read a new set of words constructed from the original characters. In general,
readers who were taught the rules of phonics could read many more new words than
those trained with a whole-word procedure.
Classroom studies comparing phonics with either whole-word or whole-language
instruction are also quite illuminating. One particularly persuasive study compared two
programmes used in 20 first-grade classrooms. Half the students were offered
traditional reading instruction, which included the use of phonics drills and applications.
The other half were taught using an individualised method that drew from their
experiences with languages; these children produces their own booklets of stories and
developed sets of words to be recognised (common components of the whole-language
approach). This study found that the first group scored higher at year’s end on tests of
reading and comprehension.
E
If researchers are so convinced about the need of phonics instruction, why does the
debate continue? Because the controversy is emmeshed in the philosophical differences
between traditional and progressive (or new) approaches, differences that have divided
educators for years. The progressive challenge the results of laboratory tests and
Page 3
Passage 3 How should reading be taught?
3
classroom studies on the basis of a broad philosophical skepticism about the values of
such research. They champion student-centred learned and teacher empowerment.
Sadly, they fail to realise that these very admirable educational values are equally
consistent with the teaching of phonics.
F
If schools of education insisted that would-be reading teachers learned something about
the vast research in linguistics and psychology that bears on reading, their graduates
would be more eager to use phonics and would be prepared to do so effectively. They
could allow their pupils to apply the principles of phonics while reading for pleasure.
Using whole-language activities to supplement phonics instruction certainly helps to
make reading fun and meaningful for children, so no one would want to see such tools
discarded. Indeed, recent work has indicated that the combination of literature-based
instruction and phonics is more powerful than either method used alone.
Teachers need to strike a balance. But in doing so, we urge them to remember that
reading must be grounded in a firm understanding of the connections between letters
and sounds. Educators who deny this reality are neglecting decades of research. They
are also neglecting the needs of their students.
Page 4
Passage 3 How should reading be taught?
4
Questions 27-31
Reading Passage 3 has six sections, A-F.
Choose the correct heading for sections B-F from the list of headings below.
Write the correct number, i-ix, in boxes 27-31 on your answer sheet.
List of Headings
i Disagreement about the reading process
ii The roots of the debate
iii A combined approach
iv Methods of teaching reading
v A controversial approach
vi Inconclusive research
vii Research with learners
vii Allowing teachers more control
ix A debate amongst educators
Example
Section A ix
27 Section B
28 Section C
29 Section D
30 Section E
31 Section F
Page 5
Passage 3 How should reading be taught?
5
Questions 32-36
Do the following statements agree with the information given in Reading Passage 3?
In boxes 32-36 on your answer sheet, write
TRUE if the statement agrees with the information
FALSE if the statement contradicts the information
NOT GIVEN if there is no information on this
32 The whole-language approach relates letters to sounds.
33 Many educators believe the whole-language approach to be the most interesting
way to teach children to read.
34 Research supports the theory that we read without linking words to sounds.
35 Research has shown that the whole-word approach is less effective than the wholelanguage approach.
36 Research has shown that phonics is more successful than both the whole-word and
whole-language approaches.
Page 6
Passage 3 How should reading be taught?
6
Questions 37-40
Complete the summary of sections E and F using the list of words, A-G, below.
Write the correct letter, A-G, in boxes 37-40 on your answer sheet.
In the teaching community, 37…………………………… question the usefulness of research
into methods of teaching reading. These critics believe that 38……………………………… is
incompatible with student-centred learning. In the future, teachers need to be aware of
39………………………….. so thay they understand the importance of phonics. They should
not, however, ignore the ideas of 40………………………….. which make reading enjoyable
for learners.
A the phonics method
B the whole-word method
C the whole-language method
D traditionalists
E progressives
F linguistics
G research studies
Page 7
Passage 3 How should reading be taught?
7
ANSWER
27. iv
28. i
29. vii
30. ii
31. iii
32. FALSE
33. TRUE
34. FALSE
35. NOT GIVEN
36. TRUE
37. E
38. A
39. G
40. C
Showing the first 7 pages. Download the document to see it all.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!