Page 1
Passage 3 CARBON CAPTURE AND STORAGE
1
SECTION 3
READING PASSAGE 3
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 27-40 which are based on Reading
Passage 3 below.
CARBON CAPTURE AND STORAGE
High coal dependence
Renewable energy is much discussed, but coal still plays the greatest role in the
generation of electricity, with recent figures from the International Energy Agency
showing that China relies on it for 79% of its power, Australia for 78%, and the US for
45%. Germany has less reliance at 41%, which is also the global average. Furthermore,
many countries have large, easily accessible deposits of coal, and numerous highly
skilled miners, chemists, and engineers. Meanwhile, 70% of the world's steel production
requires coal, and plastic and rayon are usually coal derivatives.
Currently, coal-fired power plants fed voracious appetites, but they produce carbon
dioxide (CO2) in staggering amounts. Urbanites may grumble about an average monthly
electricity bill of $113, yet they steadfastly ignore the fact that they are not billed for the
6-7 million metric tons of CO2 their local plant belches out, which contribute to the 44%
of global CO2 levels from fossil-fuel emissions. Yet, as skies fill with smog and
temperatures soar, people crave clean air and cheap power.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change that advises the United Nations has
testified that the threshold of serious harm to the Earth's temperature is a mere 2°
Celsius above current levels, so it is essential to reduce carbon emissions by 80% over
the next 30 years, even as demand for energy will rise by 50%, and one proposal for this
is the adoption of carbon capture and storage (CCS).
Underground carbon storage
Currently, CO2 storage, or sequestration as it is known, is practised by the oil and gas
industry, where CO2 is pumped into oil fields to maintain pressure and ease extraction –
one metric ton dissolves out about three barrels, or separated from natural gas and
pumped out of exhausted coal fields or other deep seams. The CO2 remains
underground or is channelled into disused sandstone reservoirs. However, the sale of oil
and natural gas is profitable, so the $17-per-ton sequestration cost is easily borne. There
is also a plan for the injection of CO2 into saline aquifers, 1,000 metres beneath the
seabed, to prevent its release into the atmosphere.
Page 2
Passage 3 CARBON CAPTURE AND STORAGE
2
Carbon capture
While CO2 storage has been accomplished, its capture from power plants remains
largely hypothetical, although CCS plants throughout Western Europe and North
America are on the drawing board.
There are three main forms of CCS: pre-combustion, post-combustion, and oxy-firing. In
a 2012 paper from the US Congressional Budget Office (CBO), post-combustion capture
was viewed most favourably since existing power plants can be retrofitted with it,
whereas pre-combustion and oxy-firing mean the construction of entirely new plants.
However, pre-combustion and oxy-firing remove more CO2 than post-combustion and
generate more electricity.
Post-combustion capture means CO2 is separated from gas after coal is burnt but before
electricity is generated, while in oxy-firing, coal is combusted in pure oxygen. In precombustion, as in an Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle system (IGCC), oxygen,
coal, and water ae burnt together to produce a synthetic gas called Syngas – mainly
hydrogen – which drives two sets of turbines, firstly gas-driven ones, then, as the
cooling Syngas travel through water, steam-driven ones. Emissions from this process
contain around ten percent of the CO2 that burning coal produces.
The pros and cons of CCS
Several countries are keen to scale up CCS as it may reduce carbon emissions quickly,
and powerful lobby groups for CCS exist among professionals in mining and engineering.
Foundries and refineries that produce steel and emit carbon may also benefit, and the
oil and gas industry is interested because power-plant equipment consumes their
products. In addition, recent clean energy acts in many countries mandate that a
percentage of electricity be generated by renewables or by more energy-efficient
systems, like CCS.
As with desalination, where powerful lobbies wield influence, states sometimes find it
easier to engage in large projects involving a few players rather than change behaviours
on a more scattered household scale. Furthermore, replacing coal with zero-emission
photovoltaic (PV) cells to produce solar energy would require covering an area nearly
20,720 square kilometres, roughly twice the size of Lebanon or half of Denmark.
Still, there are many reservations about CCS. Principally, it is enormously expensive:
conservative estimates put the electricity it generates at more than five times the
current retail price. As consumers are unlikely to want to bear this price hike, massive
state subsidies would be necessary for CCS to work.
Page 3
Passage 3 CARBON CAPTURE AND STORAGE
3
The capital outlay of purchasing equipment for retrofitting existing power plants is high
enough, but the energy needed to capture CO2 means one third more coal must be
burnt, and building new CCS plants is at least 75% more expensive than retro-fitting.
Some CCS technology is untried, for example, the Syngas-driven turbines in an IGCC
system have not been used on an industrial scale. Post capture, CO2 must be
compressed into a supercritical liquid for transport and storage, which is also costly. The
Qatar Carbonates and Carbon Storage Research Centre predicts 700 million barrels per
day of this liquid would be produced if CCS were adopted modestly. It is worth noting
that current oil production is around 85 million barrels per day, so CCS would produce
eleven times more waste for burial than oil that was simultaneously being extracted.
Sequestration has been used successfully, but there are limited coal and oil fields where
optimal conditions exist. In rock that is too brittle, earthquakes could release the CO2.
Moreover, proposals to store CO2 in saline aquifers are just that - proposals:
sequestration has never been attempted in aquifers.
Most problematic of all, CCS reduces carbon emissions but does not end them,
rendering it a medium-term solution.
Alternatives
There are at least four reasonably-priced alternatives to CCS. Firstly, conventional
pulverised coal power plants are undergoing redesign so more electricity can be
produced from less coal. Before coal is phased out - as ultimately it will have to be -
these plants could be more cost-effective. Secondly, hybrid plants using natural gas and
coal could be built. Thirdly, natural gas could be used on its own. Lastly, solar power is
fast gaining credibility.
In all this, an agreed measure of cost for electricity generation must be used. This is
called a levelized cost of energy (LCOE) - an average cost of producing electricity over
the lifetime of a power plant, including construction, financing, and operation, although
pollution is not counted. In 2012, the CBO demonstrated that a new CCS plant had an
LCOE of about $0.09-0.15 per kilowatt-hour (kWh), but according to the US Energy
Information Administration, the LCOE from a conventional natural gas power plant
without CCS is $0.0686/kWh, making it the cheapest way to produce clean energy.
Solar power costs are falling rapidly. In 2013, the Los Angeles Department of Water and
Power reported that energy via a purchase agreement from a large solar plant was
$0.095/kWh, and Greentech Media, a company that reviews environmental projects,
found a 2014 New Mexico solar project that generates power for $0.0849/kWh.
Page 4
Passage 3 CARBON CAPTURE AND STORAGE
4
Still, while so much coal and so many coal-fired plants exist, decommissioning them all
may not be realistic. Whatever happens, the conundrum of cheap power and clean air
may remain unsolved for some time.
Questions 27-28
Choose the correct letter A, B, C, or D.
Write the correct letter in boxes 27-28 on your answer sheet.
27 What is the global average for electricity generated from coal?
A 41%
B 44%
C 49%
D 70%
28 What does the average American pay each month for CO2 produced by a local
power plant?
A $17
B $80
C $113
D Nothing
Questions 29-34
Label the diagrams on the following page.
Write the correct letter, A-H, in boxes 29-34 on your answer sheet.
A CO2 B Coal C Natural gas
D Oil E Saline aquifer F Steam-driven turbines
G Syngas H Syngas-driven turbines
Carbon dioxide sequestration
Page 6
Passage 3 CARBON CAPTURE AND STORAGE
6
Questions 35-40
Complete the table below.
Choose NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS AND/OR A NUMBER from the passage for each
answer.
Write your answer in boxes 35-40 on your answer sheet.
Advantages of CCS Disadvantages of CCS
Sequestration is
already used in the oil
and gas sector.
CCS may cut
35.................... in a
short time.
36.................... in
labour,
industry, and states
already support CCS.
Alternatives, like
37...................energy,
take up vast amounts
of space.
The construction of new and the conversion of
existing power plants and the liquefaction and
transport of CO2 are very costly. While sequestration
is possible, the scale would be enormous. Therefore,
CCS would need 38....................
Some CCS technology is 39..................... Gas-driven
turbines for IGCC have not been used on an industrial
scale.
Shallow underground storage may be limited; deep
ocean storage is currently impossible. Geologists fear
leaks in quake-prone regions.
Natural gas and solar PVs are cheaper. LCOE
estimates for
CCS = $0.09-15/kWh; for natural gas= 40....................;
and, for solar PV = $0.0849/kWh.
Page 7
Passage 3 CARBON CAPTURE AND STORAGE
7
ANSWER
27. A
28. D
29. A
30. C
31. E
32. B
33. G
34. F
35. carbon emissions/ carbon dioxide/ CO2 emissions
36. powerful lobbies/ lobby groups
37. solar
38. massive state subsidies
39. untried
40. $0.0686/kWh/ $0.0686 per kilowatt-hour
Showing the first 7 pages. Download the document to see it all.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!