Page 1
Passage 2 Recent stock-market crashes
1
SECTION 2
READING PASSAGE 2
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 14-27 which are based on Reading
Passage 2 below.
Recent stock-market crashes
For as long as there have been financial markets, there have been financial crises. Most
economists agree, however, that from 1994 to 2013 crashes were deeper and the
resultant troughs longer-lasting than in the 20-year period leading up to 1994. Two
notable crashes, the Nifty Fifty in the mid-l 970s and Black Monday in 1987, had an
average loss of about 40% of the value of global stocks, and recovery took 240 days
each, whereas the Dot-com and credit crises, post-1994, had an average loss of about
52%, and endured for 430 days. What economists do not agree upon is why recent
crises have been so severe or how to prevent their recurrence.
John Coates, from the University of Cambridge in the UK and a former trader for
Goldman Sachs and Deutsche Bank, believes three separate but related phenomena
explain the severity. The first is dangerous but predictable risk-taking on the part of
traders. The second is a lack of any risk-taking when markets become too volatile.
(Coates does not advocate risk-aversion since risk-taking may jumpstart a depressed
market.) The last is a new policy of transparency by the US Federal Reserve – known as
the Fed – that may have encouraged stock-exchange complacency, compounding the
dangerous risk-taking.
Many people imagine a trader to have a great head for maths and a stomach for the
rollercoaster ride of the market, but Coates downplays arithmetic skills, and doubts
traders are made of such stern stuff. Instead, he draws attention to the physiological
nature of their decisions. Admittedly, there are women in the industry, but traders are
overwhelmingly male, and testosterone appears to affect their choices.
Another common view is that traders are greedy as well as thrill-seeking. Coates has not
researched financial incentive, but blood samples taken from London traders who
engaged in simulated risk-taking exercises for him in 2013 confirmed the prevalence of
testosterone, cortisol, and dopamine – a neurotransmitter precursor to adrenalin
associated with raised blood pressure and sudden pleasure.
Page 2
Passage 2 Recent stock-market crashes
2
Certainly anyone faced with danger has a stress response involving the body's
preparation for impending movement – for what is sometimes called 'Fight or flight',
but, as Coates notes, any physical act at all produces a stress response: even a reader's
eye movement along words in this line requires cortisol and adrenalin. Neuroscientists
now see the brain not as a computer that acts neutrally, involved in a process of pure
thought, but as a mechanism to plan and carry out a movement, since every single piece
of information humans absorb has an attendant pattern of physical arousal.
For muscles to work, fuel is needed, so cortisol and adrenalin employ glucose from
other muscles and the liver. To burn the fuel, oxygen is required, so slightly deeper or
faster breathing occurs. To deliver fuel and oxygen to the body, the heart pumps a little
harder and blood pressure rises. Thus, the stress response is a normal part of life, as
well as a resource in fighting or fleeing. Indeed, it is a highly pleasurable experience in
watching an action movie, making love or pulling off a multi-million-dollar stock-market
deal.
Cortisol production also increases during exposure to uncertainty. For example, people
who live next to a train line adjust to the noise of passing trains, but visitors to their
home are disturbed. The phenomenon is equally well-known of anticipation being worse
than an event itself: sitting in the waiting room thinking about a procedure may be more
distressing than occupying the dentist's chair and having one. Interestingly, if a patient
does not know approximately when he or she will be called for that procedure, cortisol
levels are the most elevated of all. This appeared to happen with the London traders
participating in some of Coates' gambling scenarios.
When there is too much volatility in the stock market, Coates suspects adrenaline levels
decrease while cortisol levels increase, explaining why traders take fewer risks at that
time. In fact, typically traders freeze, becoming almost incapable of buying or selling
anything but the safest bonds. In Coates' opinion, the market needs investment as it
falls and at rock bottom – at such times, greed is good.
The third matter – the behaviour of the Fed – Coates thinks could be controlled, albeit
counterintuitively. Since 1994, the US Federal Reserve has adopted a policy called
Forward Guidance. Under this, the public is informed at regular intervals of the Fed's
plans for short-term interest rates. Recently, rates have been raised by small but
predictable increments. By contrast, in the past, the machinations of the Fed were
largely secret, and its interest rates fluctuated apparently randomly. Coates
hypothesises these meant traders were on guard and less likely to indulge in wild
speculation. In introducing Forward Guidance, the Fed hoped to lower stock and
Page 3
Passage 2 Recent stock-market crashes
3
housing prices; instead, before the crash of 2008, the market surged from further risktaking, like an unleashed pit bull terrier.
There are many economists who disagree with Coates, but he has provided some
physiological evidence for both traders' recklessness and immobilisation and made the
radical proposal of greater opacity at the Fed. Although, as others have noted, we could
just let more women onto the floor.
Questions 14-19
Choose the correct letter A, B, C, or D.
Write the correct letter in boxes 14-19 on your answer sheet.
14 What do most economists agree about the financial crashes from 1994 to 2013?
A They were the worst global markets had ever experienced.
B Global stocks fell around 40% for a period of 240 days.
C They were particularly acute in the US.
D They were more severe than those between 1974 and 1993.
15 What does John Coates think about risk-taking among stock-market traders?
A It is almost invariably dangerous.
B It was prevalent at Goldman Sachs and Deutsche Bank.
C It should be regulated by the US Federal Reserve.
D It can sometimes assist a weak market.
Page 4
Passage 2 Recent stock-market crashes
4
16 What is some popular belief about traders?
A They are clever, calm, and acquisitive.
B They are usually men who are good at maths.
C They love danger and seek it out.
D They do not deserve their high salaries.
17 What did Coates find in blood samples from London traders in 2013?
A They had high levels of testosterone and dopamine.
B They produced excessive glucose and oxygen.
C They experienced high blood pressure.
D They drank large amounts of alcohol.
18 How do neuroscientists now view the brain?
A As an extraordinary computer.
B As an organ to control movement.
C As the main producer of adrenaline and cortisol.
D As a significant enhancer of pleasure.
19 Why might a person wait to see a dentist have extremely high cortisol levels?
A He or she may dislike going to the dentist.
B He or she may be worried about the procedure.
C He or she may not have a specific appointment.
D He or she may not be able to afford the consultation.
Page 5
Passage 2 Recent stock-market crashes
5
Questions 20-24
Complete the flowchart below.
Choose ONE WORD ONLY from the passage for each answer
Write your answers in boxes 20-24 on your answer sheet.
Page 6
Passage 2 Recent stock-market crashes
6
Questions 25-27
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in Passage 2?
In boxes 25-27 on your answer sheet, write:
YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer.
NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer.
NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this.
25 Coates' views are held by many other economists.
26 Coates' suggestion of less transparency at the Fed is sound.
27 Raising the number of female traders may solve the problem.
Page 7
Passage 2 Recent stock-market crashes
7
ANSWER
14. D
15. D
16. C
17. A
18. B
19. C
20. volatility
21. cortisol
22. Forward
23. wild
24. Further
25. NO
26. NOT GIVEN
27. YES
Showing the first 7 pages. Download the document to see it all.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!