Page 1
Passage 3 WORLD HERITAGE DESIGNATION
1
SECTION 3
READING PASSAGE 3
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 28-40 which are based on Reading
Passage 3 below.
WORLD HERITAGE DESIGNATION
Almost all cultures raise monuments to their own achievements or beliefs, and preserve
artefacts and built environments from the past.
There has been considerable interest in saving cultural sites valuable to all humanity
since the 1950s. In particular, an international campaign to relocate pharaonic treasures
from an area in Egypt where the Aswan Dam would be built was highly successful, with
more than half the project costs bore by 50 different countries. Later, similar projects
were undertaken to save the ruins of Mohenjoh-daro in Pakistan and the Borobodur
Temple complex in Indonesia.
The idea of listing world heritage sites (WHS) that are cultural or natural was proposed
jointly by an American politician, Joseph Fisher, and a director of an environmental
agency, Russell Train, at a White House conference in 1965. These men suggested a
programme of cataloguing, naming, and conserving outstanding sites, under what
became the World Heritage Convention, adopted by UNESCO* on November 1972, and
effective from December 1975. Today, 191 states and territories have ratified the
convention, making it one of the most inclusive international agreements of all time.
The UNESCO World Heritage Committee, composed of representatives from 21 UNESCO
member states and international experts, administers the programme, albeit with a
limited budget and few real powers, unlike other international bodies, like the World
Trade Organisation or the UN Security Council.
In 2014, there were 1,007 WHS around the world: 779 of them, cultural; 197 naturals;
and, 31 mixed properties. Italy, China, and Spain are the top three countries by the
number of sites, followed by Germany, Mexico, and India.
Legally, each site is part of the territory of the state in which it is located and maintained
by that entity, but as UNESCO hopes sites will be preserved in countries both rich and
poor, it provides some financial assistance through the World Heritage Fund.
Theoretically, WHS is protected by the Geneva Convention, which prohibits acts of
hostility towards historic monuments, works of art, or places of worship.
Page 2
Passage 3 WORLD HERITAGE DESIGNATION
2
Certainly, WHS have encouraged appreciation and tolerance globally, as well as proving
a boon for local identity and the tourist industry. Moreover, the diversity of plant and
animal life has generally been maintained, and degradations associated with mining and
logging minimised.
Despite good intentions, significant threats to WHS exist, especially in the form of
conflict. The Garamba National Park in the Democratic Republic of Congo is one
example, where militias kill white rhinoceros, selling their horns to purchase weapons;
and, in 2014, Palmyra - a Roman site in northern Syria - was badly damaged by a road
built through it, as well as by shelling and looting. In fact, theft is a common problem at
WHS in under-resourced areas, while pollution, nearby construction, or natural disasters
present further dangers.
But most destructive of all is mass tourism. The huge ancient city of Angkor Wat, in
Cambodia, now has over one million visitors a year, and the nearby town of Siem Reap -
a village 20 years ago – now boasts an international airport and 300 hotels. Machu
Picchu in Peru has been inundated by tourists to the point where it may now be
endangered. Commerce has altered some sites irrevocably. Walkers along the Great
Wall near Beijing are hassled by vendors flogging every kind of item, many unrelated to
the wall itself, and extensive renovation has given the ancient wonder a Disneyland feel.
In order for a place to be listed as a WHS, it must undergo a rigorous application
process. Firstly, a state takes an inventory of its significant sites, which is called a
Tentative List, from which sites are put into a Nomination File. Two independent
international bodies, the International Council on Monuments and Sites, and the World
Conservation Union evaluate the Nomination File and make recommendations to the
World Heritage Committee. Meeting once a year, this committee determines which
sites should be added to the World Heritage List by deciding that a site meets at least
one criterion out of ten, of which six are cultural, and four are natural.
In 2003, a second convention, effective from 2008, was added to the first. The
Convention for the Safeguarding of Intangible Cultural Heritage has so far been ratified
by 139 states – a notable exception being the US. Aiming to protect traditions rather
than places, 267 elements have already been enshrined, including Cambodia's Royal
Ballet; the French gastronomic meal; and, watertight-bulkhead technology of Chinese
junks.
The World Heritage Committee hopes that the states that agree to list such elements
will also promote and support them, although, once again, commercialisation is
problematic. For instance, after the French gastronomic meal was listed in 2010,
Page 3
Passage 3 WORLD HERITAGE DESIGNATION
3
numerous French celebrity chef used the designation in advertising, and UNESCO
debated delisting the element. The US has chosen not to sign the second convention
due to implications to intellectual property rights. As things stand, with the first treaty,
the US has far fewer nominated sites than its neighbour Mexico, partly because some
Mexican sites are entire towns or city centres, and the US has no desire for its urban
planning to be restricted by world-heritage status. St Petersburg, in Russia, which has its
entire historic centre as a WHS, introduced strict planning regulations to maintain its
elegant 18th-century appearance, only to discover thousands of minor infringements by
owners preferring to do what they pleased with their properties. With intangible
elements, changes over time, due to modernisation or globalization, may be greater
than those threatening buildings. Opponents of the second convention believe
traditions should not be frozen in time, and are equally unconcerned if traditions
dwindle or die.
Although the 1972 World Heritage Convention lacks teeth, and many of its sites are
suffering, and although the 2003 Convention for the Safeguarding of Intangible Cultural
Heritage has proven less popular, it would seem that the overall performance of these
two instruments has been very good.
*The United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organisation, based in Paris,
France.
Questions 28-31
Look at the following statements and the list of countries below.
Match each statement with the correct country, A-F, below.
Write the correct letter, A-F, in boxes 28-31 on your answer sheet.
28 It has the most world heritage sites.
29 Mass tourism has seriously threatened one of its sites.
30 Two men from here put forward the idea of a convention.
31 There was international support for a project here prior to the convention.
Page 4
Passage 3 WORLD HERITAGE DESIGNATION
4
List of countries
A Pakistan B the US
C Italy D China
E Peru F France
Questions 32-35
Complete the flowchart below.
Choose ONE WORD OR A NUMBER from the passage for each answer.
Write your answers in boxes 32-35 on your answer sheet.
SITE REGISTRATION
Inventor - A state or territory takes an inventory of its important sites, called a
32....................List.
↓
Nomination File - Sites from the list above are included in a Nomination File, which is
assessed by two independent international 33.......................
↓
External File Evaluation - To be listed as a WHS, a site must meet at least
34.......................out of ten criteria. Most of these are 35......................, but there are
'some natural and mixed ones too.
Page 5
Passage 3 WORLD HERITAGE DESIGNATION
5
Questions 36-40
Complete each sentence with the correct ending, A-G, below.
Write the correct letter A-G, in boxes 36-40 on your answer sheet.
36 The Convention for the Safeguarding of Intangible Cultural Heritage is designed to
37 The World Heritage Committee worries about
38 The US refused to sign the 2003 convention due to concerns about
39 Russian property owners have been annoyed by what they see as
40 Critics of the 2003 convention are not disturbed by
A changes to or disappearance of traditions.
B price rises due to world-heritage listing.
C over-regulation connected to the world-heritage listing.
D protect traditions.
E protect built environments.
F intellectual property rights.
G the commercial exploitation of listed traditions.
Page 6
Passage 3 WORLD HERITAGE DESIGNATION
6
ANSWER
28. C
29. E
30. B
31. A
32. Tentative
33. bodies
34. 1/one
35. culture
36. D
37. G
38. F
39. C
40. A
Showing the first 6 pages. Download the document to see it all.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!