Page 1
Passage 1 PROJECT: Reform Of The Prison System In The UK
1
SECTION 1
READING PASSAGE 1
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 1-13 which are based on Reading
Passage 2 below.
PROJECT: Reform Of The Prison System In The UK
Penal progress:
The UK’s large prison population is fuelled by a high level of recidivism – when criminals
repeatedly relapse into crime. This project for a model prison tackles issues of
architecture, management and funding in an enlightened attempt to achieve lasting
rehabilitation.
Project:
The penal system is one of the most direct manifestations of the power of the state but
is often also a revealing reflection of the national psyche and the public’s attitude to
punishment and rehabilitation. Surprisingly, for a prosperous, progressive Western
democracy, the UK has a lamentable penal record. Britain’s prison population is
currently in excess of 60,000 (up 50 per cent from a decade ago) making it the secondlargest in Europe. The average cost of keeping an individual prisoner incarcerated for a
year is £27,000 (ten times the average expenditure on a secondary school pupil in the
state sector). Despite such substantial investment, over half of British prisoners reoffend within two years of release.
Such high rates of recidivism is a serious problem. It means that the prison population is
continuing to grow at an alarming rate (recently by as many as 700 a week), so
overcrowding is endemic, hampering opportunities for education and rehabilitation and
lowering staff and prisoner morale. To ease this pressure, the UK government is
investing in the prison estate at historic levels, with 12,000 new prison places proposed
within the next few years. Yet, like their nineteenth-century predecessors, Britain’s ‘new
Victorian’ prisons are designed for security and control rather than for the rehabilitation
and education which is increasingly recognised as what prisoners need. Most are poorly
educated young men under 30 (at least 60 per cent of whom are functionally illiterate
and innumerate), so without education and skills, few will be able to build meaningful
lives away from crime, no matter how often they go to prison, or how long they spend
there.
Page 2
Passage 1 PROJECT: Reform Of The Prison System In The UK
2
Any transformation of the penal system must start with the redesign of prison buildings.
Prison architecture has a clearly discernible effect on behaviour, operational efficiency,
interaction and morale. Last year, architects Buschow Henley were commissioned by a
think tank organisation working with the Home Office Prison Service to research and
develop an alternative prison model that focuses more intensely on rehabilitation
through a concentrated programme of intellectual, physical and social education. The
model is not intended as a blueprint but rather a series of principles that might be
adapted to support the wider concept of the ‘Learning Prison’ in which other aspects
such as organisation, management and funding would obviously play a part. Key to this
is the introduction of a system that groups together prisoners in small communities or
‘houses’ of between 30 and 40 inmates. This has two important consequences. First, the
more compact spatial organisation of the house reduces staff time spent on supervising
and escorting prisoners. Second, the system places educational and other facilities at
the heart of the building, within easy reach at all times of day, reinforced by a
supportive social environment. This model also enables resources to be dramatically
redeployed, from a current estimated ratio of 80:20 (costs of security versus
rehabilitation) to a predicted reversed figure of 20:80, freeing up much-needed funds to
invest in educational programmes, thereby helping to promote rehabilitation, reduce
recidivism and initiate a virtuous cycle.
In Buschow Henley’s scheme, the proposed group size of 30-40 has the potential for
social accountability – each prisoner being known within the community and personally
accountable for his behaviour. Houses are semi-autonomous, not just dormitories, with
communal, as opposed to centralized, facilities. Circulation is simplified and reduced.
Buildings are arranged in a chess-board formation, as opposed to pavilions marooned in
space, each with a discrete external area that can be productively used for sport, games
or gardening with a minimum of supervision.
Individual cells are replanned to make them less like domestic lavatories and more
conducive to learning. In an inversion of the conventional layout, the bed is placed
lengthways along the external wall at a high level, freeing up space below. Storage is
built-in and each inmate is provided with a moveable table equipped with electronic
tools for study. Washing facilities are contained in a small adjoining space (included in
the basic 8 sqm allowance) so reducing pressure on prison staff to manage inmate
hygiene and ablution. Each cell is paired with a neighbouring ‘buddy’ cell linked by
sliding doors controlled by individual prisoners to mitigate the risk of self-harm.
While this new type of prison appears to be somewhat liberal, the arrangement of
spaces and functions both inside and out is actually tightly controlled. Paradoxically,
Page 3
Passage 1 PROJECT: Reform Of The Prison System In The UK
3
however, this proscription enables a greater range of activities to take place and makes
general supervision easier. In this environment the prisoners are judged not by their
degree of conformity, but by the scope of their activities and achievements, so laying
the foundations for genuine rehabilitation. As Martin Narey, Director General of the UK
Prison Services observes, ‘We have got to accept that prison must be a humane and
constructive place, not least because all but 23 of my population are going home
someday.’
Questions 1-5
Complete each sentence with the correct ending, A-H, below.
Write the correct letter A-H in boxes 1-5 on your answer sheet.
1 The agenda of current British prison systems is primarily
2 The primary role of prisons should be
3 The new prison scheme will create
4 Existing prison architecture causes
5 The positive results of reducing the number of prisoners in one space include
A improved security, supervision and education.
B rehabilitation and education.
C reduced efficiency, morale and interaction.
D reduced risk of self-harm.
E security and control.
F an alternative prison model
G a learning environment rather than a punitive compound.
H organisation, management and funding.
Page 4
Passage 1 PROJECT: Reform Of The Prison System In The UK
4
Questions 6-9
Choose the correct letter A, B, C or D.
6 The project to reform the penal system in the UK
A is progressive.
B is inexpensive.
C will eliminate the need for supervision.
D is, primarily, to make prisoners more comfortable.
7 The proposal to create 12,000 new prison places, within the next few years, indicates
that
A prison cells are too small.
B a lot of money is invested into educating offenders.
C there is an increasing population of offenders in the UK.
D the government is getting tougher on offenders.
8 The proposed changes to prison architecture are designed primarily to
A improve the aesthetic value of the building.
B boost self-esteem and social behaviour.
C allow prisoners more living space.
D increase running costs within prisons.
9 Why is the bed placed lengthways along the external wall at a high level?
A to make room below for washing facilities
B for the improvement of the inmates’ hygiene
C to allow room below for storage and shelves
D to make room for sliding doors
Page 5
Passage 1 PROJECT: Reform Of The Prison System In The UK
5
Questions 10-13
Label the diagram below.
Write NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS from the passage for each answer.
Page 6
Passage 1 PROJECT: Reform Of The Prison System In The UK
6
ANSWER
1. E
2. B
3. G
4. C
5. A
6. A
7. C
8. B
9. C
10. (discrete) external area
11. bed
12. storage
13. sliding doors
Showing the first 6 pages. Download the document to see it all.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!