Page 1
Passage 3 Does An IQ Test Prove Creativity?
1
SECTION 3
READING PASSAGE 3
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 28-40 which are based on Reading
Passage 3 below.
Does An IQ Test Prove Creativity?
Everyone has creativity, some a lot more than others. The development of humans, and
possibly the universe, depends on it. Yet creativity is an elusive creature. What do we
mean by it? What is going on in our brains when ideas form? Does it feel the same for
artists and scientists? We asked writers and neuroscientists, pop stars and AI gurus to try
to deconstruct the creative process – and learn how we can all ignite the spark within.
A
In the early 1970s, creativity was still seen as a type of intelligence. But when more
subtle tests of IQ and creative skills were developed in the 1970s, particularly by the
father of creativity testing, Paul Torrance, it became clear that the link was not so
simple. Creative people are intelligent, in terms of IQ tests at least, but only averagely or
just above. While it depends on the discipline, in general beyond a certain level IQ does
not help boost creativity; it is necessary, but not sufficient to make someone creative.
B
Because of the difficulty of studying the actual process, most early attempts to study
creativity concentrated on personality. According to creativity specialist Mark Runco of
California State University, Fullerton, the “creative personality” tends to place a high
value on aesthetic qualities and to have broad interests, providing lots of resources to
draw on and knowledge to recombine into novel solutions. “Creatives” have an
attraction to the complexity and an ability to handle conflict. They are also usually highly
self-motivated, perhaps even a little obsessive. Less creative people, on the other hand,
tend to become irritated if they cannot immediately fit all the pieces together. They are
less tolerant of confusion. Creativity comes to those who wait, but only to those who
are happy to do so in a bit of a fog.
C
But there may be a price to pay for having a creative personality. For centuries, a link
has been made between creativity and mental illness. Psychiatrist Jamison of Johns
Hopkins University in Baltimore, Maryland, found that established artists are
significantly more likely to have mood disorders. But she also suggests that a change of
Page 2
Passage 3 Does An IQ Test Prove Creativity?
2
mood state might be the key to triggering a creative event, rather than the negative
mood itself. Intelligence can help channel this thought style into great creativity, but
when combined with emotional problems, lateral, divergent or open thinking can lead
to mental illness instead.
D
Jordan Peterson, a psychologist at the University of Toronto, Canada, believes he has
identified a mechanism that could help explain this. He says that the brains of creative
people seem more open to incoming stimuli than less creative types. Our senses are
continuously feeding a mass of information into our brains, which have to block or
ignore most of it to save us from being snowed under. Peterson calls this process latent
inhibition, and argues that people who have less of it, and who have a reasonably high
IQ with a good working memory can juggle more of the data, and so maybe open to
more possibilities and ideas. The downside of extremely low latent inhibition may be a
confusing thought style that predisposes people to mental illness. So for Peterson,
mental illness is not a prerequisite for creativity, but it shares some cognitive traits.
E
But what of the creative act itself? One of the first studies of the creative brain at work
was by Colin Martindale, a psychologist from the University of Maine in Orono. Back in
1978, he used a network of scalp electrodes to record an electroencephalogram, a
record of the pattern of brain waves, as people made up stories. Creativity has two
stages: inspiration and elaboration, each characterised by very different states of mind.
While people were dreaming up their stories, he found their brains were surprisingly
quiet. The dominant activity was alpha waves, indicating a very low level of cortical
arousal: a relaxed state, as though the conscious mind was quiet while the brain was
making connections behind the scenes. It’s the same sort of brain activity as in some
stages of sleep, dreaming or rest, which could explain why sleep and relaxation can help
people be creative. However, when these quiet-minded people were asked to work on
their stories, the alpha wave activity dropped off and the brain became busier, revealing
increased cortical arousal, more corralling of activity and more organised thinking.
Strikingly, it was the people who showed the biggest difference in brain activity
between the inspiration and development stages who produced the most creative
storylines. Nothing in their background brain activity marked them as creative or
uncreative. “It’s as if the less creative person can’t shift gear,” says Guy Claxton, a
psychologist at the University of Bristol, UK. “Creativity requires different kinds of
thinking. Very creative people move between these states intuitively.” Creativity, it
seems, is about mental flexibility: perhaps not a two-step process, but a toggling
Page 3
Passage 3 Does An IQ Test Prove Creativity?
3
between two states. In a later study, Martindale found that communication between
the sides of the brain is also important.
F
Paul Howard-Jones, who works with Claxton at Bristol, believes he has found another
aspect of creativity. He asked people to make up a story based on three words and
scanned their brains using functional magnetic resonance imaging. In one trial, people
were asked not to try too hard and just report the most obvious story suggested by the
words. In another, they were asked to be inventive. He also varied the words so it was
easier or harder to link them. As people tried harder and came up with more creative
tales, there was a lot more activity in a particular prefrontal brain region on the righthand side. These regions are probably important in monitoring for conflict, helping us to
filter out many of the unhelpful ways of combining the words and allowing us to pull out
just the desirable connections, Howard-Jones suggests. It shows that there is another
side to creativity, he says. The story-making task, particularly when we are stretched,
produces many options which we have to assess. So part of creativity is a conscious
process of evaluating and analysing ideas. The test also shows that the more we try and
are stretched, the more creative our minds can be.
G
And creativity need not always be a solitary, tortured affair, according to Teresa Amabile
of Harvard Business School. Though there is a slight association between solitary writing
or painting and negative moods or emotional disturbances, scientific creativity and
workplace creativity seem much more likely to occur when people are positive and
buoyant. In a decade-long study of real businesses, to be published soon, Amabile found
that positive moods relate positively to creativity in organisations and that the
relationship is a simple linear one. Creative thought also improves people’s moods, her
team found, so the process is circular. Time pressures, financial pressures and hardearned bonus schemes, on the other hand, do not boost workplace creativity” internal
motivation, not coercion, produces the best work.
H
Another often forgotten aspect of creativity is social. Vera John-Steiner of the University
of New Mexico says that to be really creative you need strong social networks and
trusting relationships, not just active neural networks. One vital characteristic of a highly
creative person, she says, is that they have at least one other person in their life who
doesn’t think they are completely nuts.
Page 4
Passage 3 Does An IQ Test Prove Creativity?
4
Questions 28-31
Do the following statements agree with the information given in Reading Passage 3?
In boxes 28-31 on your answer sheet, write
TRUE if the statement is true
FALSE if the statement is false
NOT GIVEN if the information is not given in the passage
28 High IQ guarantees more ability to create in one person than one with an average
score.
29 For a competitive society, individuals’ language proficiency is more important than
other abilities.
30 A wider range of resources and knowledge can be integrated into bringing about
creative approaches.
31 A creative person not necessarily suffers more mental illness.
Questions 32-36
Use the information in the passage to match the people (listed A-F) with opinions or
deeds below.
Write the appropriate letters A-F in boxes 32-36 on your answer sheet.
A Jamison
B Jordan Peterson
C Guy Claxton
D Howard-Jone
E Teresa Amabile
F Vera John-Steiner
32 Instead of producing a negative mood, a shift of mood state might be the one
important factor of inducing creative thinking.
33 Where the more positive moods individuals achieve, there is higher creativity in
organizations.
Page 5
Passage 3 Does An IQ Test Prove Creativity?
5
34 Good interpersonal relationship and trust contribute to a person with more
creativity.
35 Creativity demands different kinds of thinking that can be easily changed back and
forth.
36 A certain creative mind can be upgraded if we are put into more practice in
assessing and processing ideas.
Questions 37-40
Complete the summary paragraph described below.
In boxes 37-40 on your answer sheet, write the correct answer with NO MORE THAN
THREE WORDS.
But what of the creative act itself? In 1978, Colin Martindale made records of the
pattern of brain waves as people made up stories by applying a system constituted of
many 37…………………….. Two phrases of mind-state such as 38………………………. are found.
While people were still planning their stories, their brains show little active sign and the
mental activity was showing a very relaxed state as the same sort of brain activity as in
sleep, dreaming or relaxing. However, the experiment proved the signal of
39…………………….. went down and the brain became busier revealing increased cortical
arousal when these people who are in a laidback state were required to produce their
stories. Strikingly, it was found the people who were perceived to have the greatest
40……………………. in brain activity between two stages, produced storylines with the
highest level of creativity.
Page 6
Passage 3 Does An IQ Test Prove Creativity?
6
ANSWER
28. FALSE
29. NOT GIVEN
30. TRUE
31. TRUE
32. A
33. E
34. F
35. C
36. D
37. scalpel electrodes
38. inspiration and elaboration
39. alpha wave activity/ alpha waves
40. difference/ differences
Showing the first 6 pages. Download the document to see it all.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!