Page 1
Passage 2 Numeracy: can animals tell numbers?
1
SECTION 2
READING PASSAGE 2
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 15-27 which are based on Reading
Passage 2 below.
Numeracy: can animals tell numbers?
A
Prime among basic numerical faculties if the ability to distinguish between a larger and a
smaller, says psychologist Elizabeth Brannon. Humans can do this with ease – providing
the ratio is big enough – but do other animals share this ability? In one experiment,
rhesus monkeys and university students examined two sets of geometrical objects that
appeared briefly on a computer monitor. They had to decide which set contained more
objects. Both groups performed successfully but, importantly, Brannon’s team found
that monkeys, like humans, make more errors when two sets of objects are close in
number. The students’ performance ends up looking just like a monkey’s. It’s practically
identical, she says.
B
Humans and monkeys are mammals, in the animal family known as primates. These are
not the only animals whose numerical capacities rely on ratio, however. The same
seems to apply to some amphibians. Psychologist Claudia Uller’s team tempted
salamanders with two sets of fruit flies held in clear tubes. In a series of trials, the
researchers noted which tube the salamanders scampered towards, reasoning that if
they had a capacity to recognise the number, they would head for the larger number.
The salamanders successfully discriminated between tubes containing 8 and 16 flies
respectively, but not between 3 and 4, 4 and 6, or 8 and 12. So it seems that for the
salamanders to discriminate between two numbers, the larger must be at least twice as
big as the smaller. However, they could differentiate between 2 and 3 flies just as well
as between 1 and 2 flies, suggesting they recognise small numbers in a different way
from larger numbers.
C
Further support for this theory comes from studies of mosquitofish, which instinctively
join the biggest shoal they can. A team at the University of Padova found that while
mosquitofish can tell the difference between a group containing 3 shoal-mates and a
group containing 4, they did not show a preference between groups of 4 and 5. The
Page 2
Passage 2 Numeracy: can animals tell numbers?
2
team also found that mosquitofish can discriminate between numbers up to 16, but
only if the ratio between the fish in each shoal was greater than 2:1. This indicates that
the fish, like salamanders, possess both the approximate and precise number systems
found in more intelligent animals such as infant humans and other primates.
D
While these findings are highly suggestive, some critics argue that the animals might be
relying on other factors to complete the tasks, without considering the number itself.
‘Any study that’s claiming an animal is capable of representing number should also be
controlling for other factors,’ says Brannon. Experiments have confirmed that primates
can indeed perform numerical feats without extra clues, but what about the more
primitive animals?
E
To consider this possibility, the mosquitofish tests were repeated, this time using
varying geometrical shapes in place of fish. The team arranged these shapes so that they
had the same overall surface area and luminance even though they contained a
different number of objects. Across hundreds of trials on 14 different fish, the team
found they consistently discriminated 2 objects from 3. The team is now testing whether
mosquitofish can also distinguish 3 geometric objects from 4.
F
Even more primitive organisms may share this ability. Entomologist Jurgen Tautz sent a
group of bees down a corridor, at the end of which lay two chambers – one which
contained sugar water, which they like, while the other was empty. To test the bees’
numeracy, the team marked each chamber with a different number of geometrical
shapes – between 2 and 6. The bees quickly learned to match the number of shapes
with the correct chamber. Like the salamanders and fish, there was a limit to the bees’
mathematical prowess – they could differentiate up to 4 shapes, but failed with 5 or 6
shapes.
G
These studies still do not show whether animals learn to count through training, or
whether they are born with the skills already intact. If the latter is true, it would suggest
there was a strong evolutionary advantage to a mathematical mind. Proof that this may
be the case has emerged from an experiment testing the mathematical ability of three –
and four-day-old chicks. Like mosquitofish, chicks prefer to be around as many of their
siblings as possible, so they will always head towards a larger number of their kin. If
Page 3
Passage 2 Numeracy: can animals tell numbers?
3
chicks spend their first few days surrounded by certain objects, they become attached
to these objects as if they were family. Researchers placed each chick in the middle of a
platform and showed it two groups of balls of paper. Next, they hid the two piles behind
screens, changed the quantities and revealed them to the chick. This forced the chick to
perform simple computations to decide which side now contained the biggest number
of its “brothers”. Without any prior coaching, the chicks scuttled to the larger quantity
at a rate well above chance. They were doing some very simple arithmetic, claim the
researchers.
H
Why these skills evolved is not hard to imagine, since it would help almost any animal
forage for food. Animals on the prowl for sustenance must constantly decide which tree
has the most fruit, or which patch of flowers will contain the most nectar. There are also
other, less obvious, advantages of numeracy. In one compelling example, researchers in
America found that female coots appear to calculate how many eggs they have laid –
and add any in the nest laid by an intruder – before making any decisions about adding
to them. Exactly how ancient these skills are is difficult to determine, however. Only by
studying the numerical abilities of more and more creatures using standardised
procedures can we hope to understand the basic preconditions for the evolution of
number.
Page 4
Passage 2 Numeracy: can animals tell numbers?
4
Questions 15-21
Answer the table below.
Choose NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS AND/OR A NUMBER from the passage for each
answer.
Write your answers in boxes 15-21 on your answer sheet
Animal numeracy
Subjects Experiments Results
Mammals and birds
rhesus
monkeys and
humans
looked at two sets of
geometrical objects on a
computer screen
Performance of the two
groups is almost
15………………..
chicks
chose between two sets
of 16……………….. which
are altered
chicks can do
calculations in order to
choose a larger group
coots
behaviour of female birds
was observed
A bird seems to have
ability to 17………………..
Amphibians, fish and insects
salamanders
offered clear tubes
containing different
quantities of
18……………….
salamanders distinguish
between numbers over
four if the bigger
number is at least two
times larger
19………………..
shown real shoals and
later artificial ones of
geometrical shapes;
these are used to check
the influence of total
20……………… and
brightness
subjects know the
difference between two
and three and possibly
three and four, but not
between four and five
bees Had to learn where
21……………. was stored
could soon choose the
correct place
Page 5
Passage 2 Numeracy: can animals tell numbers?
5
Questions 22-27
Do the following statements agree with the information given in Reading Passage 2?
In boxes 22-27 on your answer sheet, write
YES if the statement is true
NO if the statement is false
NOT GIVEN if the information is not given in the passage
22 Primates are better at identifying the larger of two numbers if one is much bigger
than the other.
23 Jurgen Tautz trained the insects in his experiment to recognise the shapes of
individual numbers.
24 The research involving young chicks took place over two separate days.
25 The experiment with chicks suggests that some numerical ability exists in newborn
animals.
26 Researchers have experimented by altering quantities of nectar or fruit available to
certain wild animals.
27 When assessing the number of eggs in their nest, coots take into account those of
other birds.
Page 6
Passage 2 Numeracy: can animals tell numbers?
6
ANSWER
15. identical
16. balls of paper
17. Count/ calculate eggs
18. fruits flies
19. mosquitofish
20. surface area
21. sugar water
22. TRUE
23. FALSE
24. NOT GIVEN
25. TRUE
26. NOT GIVEN
27. TRUE
Showing the first 6 pages. Download the document to see it all.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!