Page 1
Passage 1 Organic farming and chemical fertilisers
1
SECTION 1
READING PASSAGE 1
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 1-13 which are based on Reading
Passage 1 below.
Organic farming and chemical fertilisers
A
The world’s population continues to climb. And despite the rise of high-tech agriculture,
800 million people don’t get enough to eat. Clearly, it’s time to rethink the food we eat
and where it comes from. Feeding 9 billion people will take more than the same old
farming practices, especially if we want to do it without felling rainforests and planting
every last scrap of prairie. Finding food for all those people will tax farmers’ – and
researches’ – ingenuity to the limit. Yet already, precious aquifers that provide irrigation
water for some of the world’s most productive farmlands are drying up or filling with
seawater, and arable land in China is eroding to create vast dust storms that redden
sunsets as far away as North America. “Agriculture must become the solution to
environmental problems in 50 years. If we don’t have systems that make the
environment better – not just hold the fort-then we’re in trouble,” says Kenneth
Cassman, an agronomist at the University of Nebraska at Lincoln. That view was echoed
in January by the Curry report, a government panel that surveyed the future of farming
and food in Britain.
B
It’s easy to say agriculture has to do better, but what should this friendly farming of the
future look like? Concerned consumers come up short at this point, facing what appears
to be an ever-widening ideological divide. In one corner are the techno-optimists who
put their faith in genetically modified crops, improved agrochemicals and computerenhanced machinery; in the other are advocates of organic farming, who reject artificial
chemicals and embrace back-to-nature techniques such as composting. Both sides cite
plausible science to back their claims to the moral high ground, and both bring enough
passion to the debate for many people to come away thinking we’re faced with a stark
choice between two mutually incompatible options.
C
Not so. If you take off the ideological blinkers and simply ask how the world can produce
the food it needs with the least environmental cost, a new middle way opens. The key is
Page 2
Passage 1 Organic farming and chemical fertilisers
2
sustainability: whatever we do must not destroy the capital of soil and water we need to
keep on producing. Like today’s organic farming, the intelligent farming of the future
should pay much more attention to the health of its soil and the ecosystem it’s part of.
But intelligent farming should also make shrewd and locally appropriate use of chemical
fertilisers and pesticides. The most crucial ingredient in this new style of agriculture is
not chemicals but information about what’s happening in each field and how to
respond. Yet ironically, this key element may be the most neglected today.
D
Clearly, organic farming has all the warm, fuzzy sentiment on its side. An approach that
eschews synthetic chemicals surely runs no risk of poisoning land and water. And its
emphasis on building up natural ecosystems seems to be good for everyone. Perhaps
these easy assumptions explain why sales of organic food across Europe are increasing
by at least 50 per cent per year.
E
Going organic sounds idyllic – but it’s native, too. Organic agriculture has its own suite of
environmental costs, which can be worse than those of conventional farming, especially
if it were to become the world norm. But more fundamentally, the organic versuschemical debate focuses on the wrong question. The issue isn’t what you put into a
farm, but what you get out of it, both in terms of crop yields and pollutants, and what
condition the farm is in when you’re done.
F
Take chemical fertilisers, which deliver nitrogen, an essential plant nutrient, to crops
along with some phosphorus and potassium. It is a mantra of organic farming that these
fertilisers are unwholesome, and plant nutrients must come from natural sources. But in
fact, the main environmental damage done by chemical fertilisers as opposed to any
other kind is through greenhouse gases-carbon dioxide from the fossil fuels used in their
synthesis and nitrogen oxides released by their degradation. Excess nitrogen from
chemical fertilisers can pollute groundwater, but so can excess nitrogen from organic
manures.
G
On the other hand, relying solely on chemical fertilisers to provide soil nutrients without
doing other things to build healthy soil is damaging. Organic farmers don’t use chemical
fertilisers, so they are very good at building soil fertility by working crop residues and
Page 3
Passage 1 Organic farming and chemical fertilisers
3
manure into the soil, rotating grain with legumes that fix atmospheric nitrogen, and
other techniques.
H
This generates vital soil nutrient and also creates a soil that is richer in organic matter,
so it retains better and is hospitable to the crop’s roots and creatures such as
earthworms that help maintain soil fertility. Such soil also holds water better and
therefore make more efficient use of both rainfall and irrigation water. And organic
matter ties up CO2 in the soil, helping to offset emissions from burning fossil fuels and
reduce global warming.
I
Advocates of organic farming like to point out that fields managed in this way can
produce yields just as high as fields juiced up with synthetic fertilisers. For example, Bill
Liebhardt, research manager at the Rodale Institute in Kutztown, Pennsylvania, recently
compiled the results of such comparisons for corn, wheat, soybeans and tomatoes in
the US and found that the organic fields averaged between 94 and 100 per cent of the
yields of nearby conventional crops.
J
But this optimistic picture tells only half the story. Farmers can’t grow such crops every
year if they want to maintain or build soil nutrient without synthetic fertilisers. They
need to alternate with soil-building crops such as pasture grasses and legumes such as
alfalfa. So in the long term, the yield of staple grains such as wheat, rice and corn must
go down. This is the biggest cost of organic farming. Vaclav Smil of the University of
Manitoba in Winnipeg, Canada, estimates that if farmers worldwide gave up the 80
million tonnes of synthetic fertiliser they now use each year, total grain production
would fall by at least half. Either farmer would have to double the amount of land they
cultivate – at catastrophic cost to natural habitats – or billions of people would starve.
K
That doesn’t mean farmers couldn’t get by with less fertiliser. Technologically advanced
farmers in wealthy countries, for instance, can now monitor their yields hectare by
hectare, or even more finely, throughout a huge field. They can then target their
fertiliser to the parts of the field where it will do the most good, instead of responding
to average conditions. This increases yield and decreases fertiliser use. Eventually,
farmers may incorporate long-term weather forecasts into their planning as well, so that
Page 4
Passage 1 Organic farming and chemical fertilisers
4
they can cut back on fertiliser use when the weather is likely to make harvests poor
anyway, says Ron Olson, an agronomist with Cargill Fertilizer in Tampa, Florida.
L
Organic techniques certainly have their benefits, especially for poor farmers. But strict
“organic agriculture”, which prohibits certain technologies and allows others, isn’t
always better for the environment. Take herbicides, for example. These can leach into
waterways and poison both wildlife and people. Just last month, researchers led by
Tyrone Hayes at the University of California at Berkeley found that even low
concentrations of atrazine, the most commonly used weedkiller in the US, can prevent
frog tadpoles from developing properly.
Questions 1-4
Use the information in the passage to match the people (listed A-D) with opinions or
deeds below.
Write the appropriate letters A-D in boxes 1-4 on your answer sheet.
A Vaclav Smil
B Bill Liebhardt
C Kenneth Cassman
D Ron Olson
1 Use of chemical fertilizer can be optimised by combining weather information.
2 Organic framing yield is nearly equal to traditional ones.
3 Better agricultural setting is a significant key to solve environmental tough nut.
4 Substantial production loss would happen in case all farmers shifted from using
synthetic fertiliser.
Page 5
Passage 1 Organic farming and chemical fertilisers
5
Questions 5-9
Do the following statements agree with the information given in Reading Passage 1?
In boxes 5-9 on your answer sheet, write
YES if the statement agrees with the information
NO if the statement contradicts the information
NOT GIVEN if there is no information on this
5 Increasing population, draining irrigation, eroding farmland push agricultural industry
to extremity.
6 There are only two options for farmers; they use chemical fertiliser or natural
approach.
7 Chemical fertilizer currently is more expensive than the natural fertilisers.
8 In order to keep nutrient in the soil, organic farmers need to rotate planting method.
9 “organic agriculture” is the way that environment-damaging technologies are all
strictly forbidden.
Questions 10-13
Complete the following summary of the paragraph of Reading Passage
Using NO MORE THAN TWO WORDS from the Reading Passage for each answer.
Write your answers in boxes 10-13 on your answer sheet.
Several 10…………………….. approaches need to be applied in order that global population
wouldn’t go starved. A team called 11……………………… repeated the viewpoint of a
scholar by a survey in British farming. More and more European farmers believe in
12……………………….. farming these years. The argument of organic against
13……………………….. seems in an inaccurate direction.
Page 6
Passage 1 Organic farming and chemical fertilisers
6
ANSWER
1. D
2. B
3. C
4. A
5. YES
6. NO
7. NOT GIVEN
8. YES
9. NO
10. farming
11. curry
12. natural/organic
13. chemical
Showing the first 6 pages. Download the document to see it all.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!