Page 1
Passage 2 Can we call it “Art”? 2
1
SECTION 2
READING PASSAGE 2
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 14-26 which are based on Reading
Passage 2 below.
Can we call it “Art”? (2)
Life-Casting and Art
Julian Bames explores the questions posed by Life-Casts, an exhibition of plaster moulds
of living people and objects which were originally used for scientific purposes
A
Art changes over time and our idea of what art is changes too. For example, objects
originally intended for devotional, ritualistic or re-creational purposes may be
recategorized as art by members of other later civilisations, such as our own, which no
longer respond to these purposes.
B
What also happens is that techniques and crafts which would have been judged
inartistic at the time they were used are reassessed. Life-casting is an interesting
example of this. It involved making a plaster mould of a living person or thing. This was
complex, technical work, as Benjamin Robert Haydon discovered when he poured 250
litres of plaster over his human model and nearly killed him. At the time, the casts were
used for medical research and, consequently, in the nineteenth century life-casting was
considered inferior to sculpture in the same way that, more recently, photography was
thought to be a lesser art than painting. Both were viewed as unacceptable shortcuts by
the ‘senior’ arts. Their virtues of speed and unwavering realism also implied their
limitations; they left little or no room for the imagination.
C
For many, life-casting was an insult to the sculptor’s creative genius. In an infamous
lawsuit of 1834, a moulder whose mask of the dying French emperor Napoleon had
been reproduced and sold without his permission was judged to have no rights to the
image. In other words, he was specifically held not to be an artist. This judgement
reflect the view of established members of the nineteenth-century art world such as
Rodin, who commented that life-casting ‘happens fast but it doesn’t make Art’. Some
Page 2
Passage 2 Can we call it “Art”? 2
2
even feared that ‘if too much nature was allowed in, it would lead Art away from its
proper course of the Ideal.
D
The painter Gauguin, at the end of the nineteenth century, worried about future
developments in photography. If ever the process went into colour, what painter would
labour away at a likeness with a brush made from squirrel-tail? But painting has proved
robust. Photography has changed it, of course, just as the novel had to reassess
narrative after the arrival of the cinema. But the gap between the senior and junior arts
was always narrower than the traditionalists implied. Painters have always used
technical back-up such as studio assistants to do the boring bits, while apparently lesser
crafts involve great skill, thought, preparation and, depending on how we define it,
imagination.
E
Time changes our view in another way, too. Each new movement implies a
reassessment of what has gone before. What is done now alters what was done before.
In some cases this is merely self-serving, with the new art using the old to justify itself. It
seems to be saying, look at how all of that points to this! Aren’t we clever to be the
culmination of all that has gone before? But usually it is a matter of re-alerting the
sensibility, reminding us not to take things for granted. Take, for example, the cast of
the hand of a giant from a circus, made by an anonymous artist around 1889, an item
that would now sit happily in any commercial or public gallery. The most significant
impact of this piece is on the eye, in the contradiction between unexpected size and
verisimilitude. Next, the human element kicks in, you note that the nails are dirtencrusted, unless this is the caster’s decorative addition, and the fingertips extend far
beyond them. Then you take in the element of choice, arrangement, art if you like, in
the neat, pleated, buttoned sleeve-end that gives the item balance and variation of
texture. This is just a moulded hand, yet the part stands utterly for the whole. It reminds
us slyly, poignantly, of the full-size original.
F
But is it art? And, if so, why? These are old tediously repeated questions to which artists
have often responded, ‘It is art because I am an artist and therefore what I do is art.
However, what doesn’t work for literature works much better for art – works of art do
float free of their creators’ intensions. Over time the “reader” does become more
powerful. Few of us can look at a medieval altarpiece as its painter intended. We believe
too little and aesthetically know too much, so we recreate and find new fields of
Page 3
Passage 2 Can we call it “Art”? 2
3
pleasure in the work. Equally, the lack of artistic intention of Paul Richer and other
forgotten craftsmen who brushed oil onto flesh, who moulded, cast and decorated in
the nineteenth century is now irrelevant. What counts is the surviving object and our
response to it. The tests are simple: does it interest the eye, excite the brain, move the
mind to reflection and involve the heart. It may, to use the old dichotomy, be beautiful
but it is rarely true to any significant depth. One of the constant pleasures of art is its
ability to come at us from an unexpected angle and stop us short in wonder.
Questions 14-18
The Reading Passage has six paragraphs A-F
Which paragraph contains the following information?
Write the correct letter A-F, in boxes 14-18 on your answer sheet.
14 an example of a craftsman’s unsuccessful claim to ownership of his work
15 an example of how trends in art can change attitudes to an earlier work
16 the original function of a particular type of art
17 ways of assessing whether or not an object is art
18 how artists deal with the less interesting aspects of their work
Questions 19-24
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in Reading Passage 2?
In boxes 19-24 on your answer sheet, write
YES if the statement is true
NO if the statement is false
NOT GIVEN if the information is not given in the passage
Page 4
Passage 2 Can we call it “Art”? 2
4
19 Nineteenth-century sculptors admired the speed and realism of life-casting.
20 Rodin believed the quality of the life-casting would improve if a slower process were
used.
21 The importance of painting has decreased with the development of colour
photography.
22 Life-casting requires more skill than sculpture does.
23 New art encourages us to look at earlier work in a fresh way.
24 The intended meaning of a work of art can get lost over time.
Questions 25-26
Choose the correct letter, A, B, C or D.
Write the correct letter in boxes 25 and 26 on your answer sheet.
25 The most noticeable contrast in the cast of the giant’s hand is between the
A dirt and decoration
B size and realism
C choice and arrangement
D balance and texture
26 According to the writer, the importance of any artistic object lies in
A the artist’s intentions
B the artist’s beliefs
C the relevance it has to modern life
D the way we respond to it
Page 5
Passage 2 Can we call it “Art”? 2
5
ANSWER
14. C
15. E
16. B
17. F
18. D
19. NO
20. NO
21. NO
22. NOT GIVEN
23. NO
24. YES
25. B
26. D
Showing the first 5 pages. Download the document to see it all.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!