Trang 1
Passage 2 Are Artists Liars?
1
SECTION 2
READING PASSAGE 2
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 14-26 which are based on Reading
Passage 2 below.
Are Artists Liars?
A
Shortly before his death, Marlon Brando was working on a series of instructional videos
about acting, to he called "Lying for a Iiving”. On the surviving footage, Brando can he
seen dispensing gnomic advice on his craft to a group of enthusiastic, if somewhat
bemused, Hollywood stars, including Leonardo Di Caprio and Sean Penn. Brando also
recruited random people from the Los Angeles street and persuaded them to improvise
(the footage is said to include a memorable scene featuring two dwarves and a giant
Samoan). "If you can lie, you can act." Brando told Jod Kaftan, a writer for Rolling Stone
and one of the few people to have viewed the footage. “Are you good at lying?” asked
Kaftan. "Jesus." said Brando, “I'm fabulous at it".
B
Brando was not the first person to note that the line between an artist and a liar is a line
one. If art is a kind of lying, then lying is a form of art, albeit of a lower order-as Oscar
Wilde and Mark Twain have observed. Indeed, lying and artistic storytelling spring from
a common neurological root-one that is exposed in the cases of psychiatric patients who
suffer from a particular kind of impairment. Both liars and artists refuse to accept the
tyranny of reality. Both carefully craft stories that are worthy of belief - a skill requiring
intellectual sophistication, emotional sensitivity and physical self-control (liars are
writers and performers of their own work). Such parallels are hardly coincidental, as I
discovered while researching my book on lying.
C
A case study published in 1985 by Antonio Damasio, a neurologist, tells the story of a
middle-aged woman with brain damage caused by a series of strokes. She retained
cognitive abilities, including coherent speech, but what she actually said was rather
unpredictable. Checking her knowledge of contemporary events, Damasio asked her
about the Falklands War. In the language of psychiatry, this woman was
“confabulating”. Chronic confabulation is a rare type of memory problem that affects a
small proportion of brain damaged people. In the literature it is defined as "the
Trang 2
Passage 2 Are Artists Liars?
2
production of fabricated, distorted or misinterpreted memories about oneself or the
world, without the conscious intention to deceive”. Whereas amnesiacs make errors of
omission, there are gaps in their recollections they find impossible to fill - confabulators
make errors of commission: they make tilings up. Rather than forgetting, they are
inventing. Confabulating patients are nearly always oblivious to their own condition, and
will earnestly give absurdly implausible explanations of why they're in hospital, or
talking to a doctor. One patient, asked about his surgical sear, explained that during the
Second World War he surprised a teenage girl who shot him three times in the head,
killing him, only for surgery to bring him back to life. The same patient, when asked
about his family, described how at various times they had died in his arms, or had been
killed before his eyes. Others tell yet more fantastical tales, about trips to the moon,
fighting alongside Alexander in India or seeing Jesus on the Cross. Confabulators aren’t
out to deceive. They engage in what Morris Moseovitch, a neuropsychologist, calls
“honest lying". Uncertain and obscurely distressed by their uncertainty, they are seized
by a “compulsion to narrate": a deep-seated need to shape, order and explain what they
do not understand. Chronic confabulators are often highly inventive at the verbal level,
jamming together words in nonsensical but suggestive ways: one patient, when asked
what happened to Queen Marie Antoinette of France, answered that she had been
“suicided" by her family. In a sense, these patients are like novelists, as described by
Henry James: people on whom "nothing is wasted". Unlike writers, however, they have
little or no control over their own material.
D
The wider significance of this condition is what it tells us about ourselves. Evidently,
there is a gushing river of verbal creativity in the normal human mind, from which both
artistic invention and lying are drawn. We are born storytellers, spinning, narrative out
of our experience and imagination, straining against the leash that keeps us tethered to
reality. This is a wonderful thing; it is what gives us out ability to conceive of alternative
futures and different worlds. And it helps us to understand our own lives through the
entertaining stories of others. But it can lead us into trouble, particularly when we try to
persuade others that our inventions are real. Most of the time, as our stories bubble up
to consciousness, we exercise our cerebral censors, controlling which stories we tell,
and to whom. Yet people lie for all sorts of reasons, including the fact that confabulating
can be dangerously fun.
E
During a now-famous libel case in 1996, Jonathan Aitken, a former cabinet minister,
recounted a tale to illustrate the horrors he endured after a national newspaper tainted
Trang 3
Passage 2 Are Artists Liars?
3
his name. The case, which stretched on for more than two years, involved a series of
claims made by the Guardian about Aitken's relationships with Saudi arms dealers,
including meetings he allegedly held with them on a trip to Paris while he was a
government minister. Whitt amazed many in hindsight was the sheer superfluity of the
lies Aitken told during his testimony. Aitken’s case collapsed in June 1997, when the
defence finally found indisputable evidence about his Paris trip. Until then, Aitken's
charm, fluency and flair for theatrical displays of sincerity looked as if they might bring
him victory, they revealed that not only was Aitken’s daughter not with him that day
(when he was indeed doorstepped), but also that the minister had simply got into his
car and drove off, with no vehicle in pursuit.
F
Of course, unlike Aitken, actors, playwrights and novelists are not literally attempting to
deceive us, because the rules are laid out in advance: come to the theatre, or open this
book, and we'll lie to you. Perhaps this is why we fell it necessary to invent art in the
first place: as a safe space into which our lies can be corralled, and channeled into
something socially useful. Given the universal compulsion to tell stories, art is the best
way to refine and enjoy the particularly outlandish or insight till ones. But that is not the
whole story. The key way in which artistic “lies" differ from normal lies, and from the
"honest lying” of chronic confabulators, is that they have a meaning and resonance
beyond their creator. The liar lies on behalf of himself; the artist tell lies on behalf of
everyone. If writers have a compulsion to narrate, they compel themselves to find
insights about the human condition. Mario Vargas Llosa has written that novels “express
a curious truth that can only he expressed in a furtive and veiled fashion, masquerading
as what it is not.” Art is a lie whose secret ingredient is truth.
Trang 4
Passage 2 Are Artists Liars?
4
Questions 14-19
Reading Passage 2 has six paragraphs, A-F.
Choose the correct heading for each paragraph from the list of headings below.
Write the correct number, i-viii, in boxes 14-19 on your answer sheet.
List of Headings
i Unsuccessful deceit
ii Biological basis between liars and artists
iii How to lie in an artistic way
iv Confabulations and the exemplifiers
v The distinction between artists and common liars
vi The fine line between liars and artists
vii The definition of confabulation
viii Creativity when people lie
14 Paragraph A
15 Paragraph B
16 Paragraph C
17 Paragraph D
18 Paragraph E
19 Paragraph F
Questions 20-21
Choose TWO letters, A-E.
Write the correct letters in boxes 20-21 on your answer sheet.
Which TWO of the following statements about people suffering from confabulation are
true?
Trang 5
Passage 2 Are Artists Liars?
5
A They have lost cognitive abilities.
B They do not deliberately tell a lie.
C They are normally aware of their condition
D They do not have the impetus to explain what they do not understand.
E They try to make up stories.
Questions 22-23
Choose TWO letters, A-E.
Write the correct letters in boxes 22-23 on your answer sheet.
Which TWO of the following statements about playwrights and novelists are true?
A They give more meaning to the stories.
B They tell lies for the benefit of themselves.
C They have nothing to do with the truth out there.
D We can be misled by them if not careful.
E We know there are lies in the content.
Questions 24-26
Complete the summary below.
Choose NO MORE THAN TWO WORDS from the passage for each answer.
Write your answers in boxes 24-26 on your answer sheet.
A 24……………………. accused Jonathan Aitken, a former cabinet minister, who was selling
and buying with 25……………………... Aitken’s case collapsed in June 1997, when the
defence finally found indisputable evidence about his Paris trip. He was deemed to have
his 26……………………. They revealed that not only was Aitken’s daughter not with him
that day, but also that the minister had simply got into his car and drove off, with no
vehicle in pursuit.
Trang 6
Passage 2 Are Artists Liars?
6
ANSWER
14. vi
15. ii
16. iv
17. viii
18. i
19. v
20. B
21. E
22. A
23. E
24. national newspaper
25. arms dealers
26. victory
Hiển thị 6 trang đầu. Tải tài liệu để xem đầy đủ.
Bình luận (0)
Chưa có bình luận nào. Hãy là người đầu tiên!