Trang 1
Passage 2 Novice and Expert - Becoming an Expert
1
SECTION 2
READING PASSAGE 2
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 14-26 which are based on Reading
Passage 2 below.
Novice and Expert
Becoming an Expert
Expertise is commitment coupled with creativity. Specifically, it is the commitment of
time, energy, and resources to a relatively narrow field of study and the creative energy
necessary to generate new knowledge in that field. It takes a considerable amount of
time and regular exposure to a large number of cases to become an expert.
A
An individual enters a field a study as a novice. The novice needs to learn the guiding
principles and rules of a given task in order to perform that task. Concurrently, the
novice needs to be exposed to specific cases, or instances, that test the boundaries of
such heuristics. Generally, a novice will find a mentor to guide her through the process.
A fairly simple example would be someone learning to play chess. The novice chess
player seeks a mentor to teach her the object of the game, the number of spaces, the
names of the pieces, the function of each piece, how each piece is moved, and the
necessary conditions for winning or losing the game.
B
In time, and with much practice, the novice begins to recognize patterns of behavior
within cases and, thus, becomes a journeyman. With more practice and exposure to
increasingly complex cases, the journeyman finds patterns not only with cases but also
between cases. More importantly, the journeyman learns that these patterns often
repeat themselves over time. The journeyman still maintains regular contact with a
mentor to solve specific problems and learn more complex strategies. Returning to the
example of the chess player, the individual begins to learn patterns of opening moves,
offensive and defensive game-playing strategies, and patterns of victory and defeat.
C
When a journeyman starts to make and test hypotheses about future behavior based on
past experiences, she begins the next transition. Once she creatively generates
knowledge, rather than simply matching superficial patterns, she becomes an expert. At
Trang 2
Passage 2 Novice and Expert - Becoming an Expert
2
this point, she is confident in her knowledge and no longer needs a mentor as a guide –
she becomes responsible for her own knowledge. In the chess example, once a
journeyman begins competing against experts, makes predictions based on patterns,
and tests those predictions against actual behavior, she is generating new knowledge
and a deeper understanding of the game. She is creating her own cases rather than
relying on the cases of others.
The Power of Expertise
D
An expert perceives meaningful patterns in her domain better than non-experts. Where
a novice perceives random or disconnected date points, an expert connects regular
patterns within and between cases. This ability to identify patterns is not an innate
perceptual skill; rather it reflects the organization of knowledge after exposure to and
experience with thousands of cases. Experts have a deeper understanding of their
domains than novices do, and utilize higher-order principles to solve problems. A novice,
for example, might group objects together by color or size, whereas an expert would
group the same objects according to their function or utility. Experts comprehend the
meaning of data and weigh variables with different criteria within their domains better
than novices. Experts recognize variables that have the largest influence on a particular
problem and focus their attention on those variables.
E
Experts have better domain-specific short-term and long-term memory than novices do.
Moreover, experts perform tasks in their domains faster than novices and commit fewer
errors while problem solving. Interestingly, experts go about solving problems
differently than novices. Experts spend more time thinking about a problem to fully
understand it at the beginning of a task than do novice, who immediately seek to find a
solution. Experts use their knowledge of previous cases as a context for creating mental
models to solve given problems.
F
Better at self-monitoring than novices, experts are more aware of instances where they
have committed errors or failed to understand a problem. Experts check their solutions
more often than novices and recognize when they are missing information necessary for
solving a problem. Experts are aware of the limits of their domain knowledge and apply
their domain’s heuristics to solve problems that fall outside of their experience base.
Trang 3
Passage 2 Novice and Expert - Becoming an Expert
3
The Paradox of Expertise
G
The strengths of expertise can also be weakness. Although one would expect experts to
be good forecasters, they are not particularly good at making predictions about the
future. Since the 1930s, researchers have been testing the ability of experts to make
forecasts. The performance of experts has been tested against actuarial tables to
determine if they are better at making predictions than simple statistical models.
Seventy years later, with more than two hundred experiments in different domains, it is
clear that the answer is no. if supplied with an equal amount of data about a particular
case, an actuarial table is as good, or better, than an expert at making calls about the
future. Even if an expert is given more specific case information than is available to the
statistical model, the expert does not tend to outperform the actuarial table.
H
Theorists and researchers differ when trying to explain why experts are less accurate
forecasters than statistical models. Some have argued that experts, like all humans, are
inconsistent when using mental models to make predictions. A number of researchers
point to human biases to explain unreliable expert predictions. A number of researchers
point to human biases to explain unreliable expert predictions. During the last 30 years,
researchers have categorized, experimented, and theorized about the cognitive aspects
of forecasting. Despite such efforts, the literature shows little consensus regarding the
causes or manifestation of human bias.
Trang 4
Passage 2 Novice and Expert - Becoming an Expert
4
Questions 14-18
Complete the flow chart.
Choose NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS from the passage for each answer.
Write your answers in boxes 14-18 on your answer sheet.
From a novice to an expert
Novice:
↓
needs 14 ……………… and ……………… to perform a given
task;
exposed to specific cases;
guided by a 15 ………………. Through learning
Journeyman
↓
starts to identify 16 ……………… within and between
cases;
often exposed to 17 ……………… cases;
contacts a mentor when facing difficult problems
Expert Create predictions and new 18 ……………….;
performs task independently without the help of a
mentor
Questions 19-23
Do the following statements agree with the information given in Reading Passage 2?
In boxes 19-23 on your answer sheet, write
TRUE if the statement is true
FALSE if the statement is false
NOT GIVEN if the information is not given in the passage
19 Novices and experts use the same system to classify objects.
20 A novice’s training is focused on memory skills.
21 Experts have higher efficiency than novices when solving problems in their own
field.
22 When facing a problem, a novice always tries to solve it straight away.
23 Experts are better at recognizing their own mistakes and limits
Trang 5
Passage 2 Novice and Expert - Becoming an Expert
5
Questions 24-26
Complete the following summary of the paragraphs of Reading Passage 2.
Using NO MORE THAN TWO WORDS from the Reading Passage for each answer.
Write your answers in boxes 24-26 on your answer sheet.
Though experts are quite effective at solving problems in their own domains, their
strengths can also be turned against them. Studies have shown that experts are less
24………………….. at making predictions than statistical models. Some researchers
theorise it is because experts can also be inconsistent like all others. Yet some believe it
is due to 25………………., but there isn’t a great deal of 26………………… as to its cause and
manifestation.
Trang 6
Passage 2 Novice and Expert - Becoming an Expert
6
ANSWER
14. guiding principles and rules
15. mentor
16. patterns of behavior/patterns
17. complex
18. knowledge
19. FALSE
20. NOT GIVEN
21. TRUE
22. TRUE
23. TRUE
24. accurate
25. human bias
26. consensus
Hiển thị 6 trang đầu. Tải tài liệu để xem đầy đủ.
Bình luận (0)
Chưa có bình luận nào. Hãy là người đầu tiên!