Trang 1
Passage 2 Therapeutic Jurisprudence
1
SECTION 2
READING PASSAGE 2
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 14-26 which are based on Reading
Passage 2 below.
Therapeutic Jurisprudence:
An Overview
Therapeutic jurisprudence is the study of the role of the law as a therapeutic agent. It
examines the law’s impact on emotional life and on psychological well-being, and the
therapeutic and antitherapeutic consequences of the law. It is most applicable to the
fields of mental health law, criminal law, juvenile law and family law.
The general aim of therapeutic jurisprudence is the humanizing of the law and
addressing the human, emotional and psychological side of the legal process. It
promotes the perspective that the law is a social force that produces behaviours and
consequences. Therapeutic jurisprudence strives to have laws made or applied in a
more therapeutic way so long as other values, such as justice and due process, can be
fully respected. It is important to recognise that therapeutic jurisprudence does not
itself suggest that therapeutic goals should trump other goals. It does not support
paternalism or coercion by any means. It is simply a way of looking at the law in a richer
way and then bringing to the table some areas and issues that previously have gone
unnoticed. Therapeutic jurisprudence simply suggests that we think about the
therapeutic consequences of law and see if they can be factored into the processes of
law-making, lawyering, and judging.
The law can be divided into the following categories: (1) legal rules, (2) legal procedures,
such as hearings and trials and (3) the roles of legal actors – the behaviour of judges,
lawyers, and of therapists acting in a legal context. Much of what legal actors do has an
impact on the psychological well-being or emotional life of persons affected by the law,
for example, in the dialogues that judges have with defendants or that lawyers have
with clients. Therefore, therapeutic jurisprudence is especially applicable to this third
category.
Therapeutic jurisprudence is a relatively new phenomenon. In the early days of the law,
attitudes were very different and efforts were focused primarily on what was wrong
with various sorts of testimony. While there were good reasons for that early emphasis,
an exclusive focus on what is wrong, rather than also looking at what is right and how
Trang 2
Passage 2 Therapeutic Jurisprudence
2
these aspects could be further developed, is seriously shortsighted. Therapeutic
jurisprudence focuses attention on this previously under-appreciated aspect,
encouraging us to look very hard for promising development and to borrow from the
behavioural science literature, even when this literature has nothing obviously to do
with the law. It encourages people to think creatively about how promising
developments from other fields might be brought into the legal system.
Recently, as a result of this multidisciplinary approach, certain kinds of rehabilitative
programmes have begun to emerge that looks rather promising. One type of cognitive
behavioural treatment encourages offenders to prepare relapse prevention plans which
require them to think through the chain of events that lead to criminality. These
reasoning and rehabilitation-type programmes teach offenders cognitive self-change, to
stop and think and figure out consequences, to anticipate high-risk situations, and to
learn to avoid or cope with them. These programmes, so far, seem to be reasonably
successful.
From a therapeutic jurisprudence standpoint, the question is how these programmes
might be brought into the law. In one obvious sense, these problem-solving, reasoning
and rehabilitation-type programmes can be made widely available in correctional and
community settings. A way of linking them even more to the law, of course, would be to
make them part of the legal process itself. The suggestion here is that if a judge or
parole board becomes familiar with these techniques and is about to consider someone
for probation, the judge might say. ‘I’m going to consider you but I want you to come up
with a preliminary relapse prevention plan that we will use as a basis for discussion. I
want you to figure out why I should grant you probation and why I should be
comfortable that you’re going to succeed. In order for me to feel comfortable, I need to
know what you regard to be high-risk situations and how you’re going to avoid them or
cope with them.’
If that approach is followed, courts will be promoting cognitive self-change as part and
parcel of the sentencing process itself. The process may operate this way; an offender
would make a statement like ‘I realise I mess up on Friday nights; therefore, I propose
that I will stay at home on Friday nights.’ Suddenly, it is not a judge imposing something
on the offender. It’s something that the offender has come up with him or herself, so he
or she should think it is fair. If a person has a voice in his rehabilitation, then he is more
likely to feel a commitment to it, and with that commitment, presumably, compliance
will increase dramatically.
Trang 3
Passage 2 Therapeutic Jurisprudence
3
Questions 14-20
Complete the notes below.
Choose NO MORE THAN ONE WORD from the passage for each answer.
NOTES: Therapeutic Jurisprudence
Therapeutic Jurisprudence:
study of the law as a therapeutic 14…………………………….. and the therapeutic and
15………………………… consequences of the law.
Goal:
the 16 ……………………………. of the law, but NOT at the expense of 17………………………………
and due process.
Applicable to:
especially applicable to the role of legal 18 ……………………………… such as judges and
lawyers
Therapeutic jurisprudence = new attitude
1. It asks people to seek out 19……………………………. developments, not problems.
2. It urges people to think 20 …………………………… and borrow from other fields.
Trang 4
Passage 2 Therapeutic Jurisprudence
4
Questions 21-23
Complete the sentences.
Choose NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS from the passage for each answer.
21 One aspect of cognitive behavioural treatment includes the preparation of
…………………………. By offenders.
22 The treatment requires offenders to consider the …………………………. that lead to a
crime being committed.
23 Treatment programmes encourage offenders to recognise ……………………………
before they happen, and know what to do in case they do happen.
Questions 24-26
Do the following statements agree with the information given in Reading Passage 2?
In boxes 24-26 on your answer sheet, write
TRUE if the statement agrees with the information
FALSE if the statement contradicts the information
NOT GIVEN if there is no information on this
24 The use of rehabilitative programmes has been proved to greatly reduce the chance
of a criminal re-offending.
25 Therapeutic jurisprudence aims to make cognitive behavioural treatment a part of
the legal process itself.
26 Offenders might be encouraged by judges to take part in deciding what their
punishment should be.
Trang 5
Passage 2 Therapeutic Jurisprudence
5
ANSWER
14. agent
15. antitherapeutic
16. humanising
17. justice
18. actors
19. promising
20. creatively
21. relapse prevention plans
22. chain of events
23. high-risk situations
24. NOT GIVEN
25. TRUE
26. FALSE
Hiển thị 5 trang đầu. Tải tài liệu để xem đầy đủ.
Bình luận (0)
Chưa có bình luận nào. Hãy là người đầu tiên!