Trang 1
Passage 1 Plain English Campaign
1
SECTION 1
READING PASSAGE 1
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 1-13 which are based on Reading
Passage 1 below.
Plain English Campaign
A
We launched Plain English Campaign in 1979 with a ritual shredding of appalling
government and municipal council forms in Parliament Square, London. We had become
so fed up of people visiting our advice centre in Salford, Greater Manchester, to
complain about incomprehensible forms that we thought we ought to take action. At
the time the shredding seemed like merely throwing sand in the eyes of the charging
lion, but it briefly caught the public imagination and left an impression on government
and business. Although we’re pleased with the new plain English awareness in
government departments, many local councils and businesses maintain a stout
resistance to change. One council began a letter to its tenants about a rent increase
with two sentences averaging 95 words, full of bizarre housing finance jargon and waffle
about Acts of Parliament. The London Borough of Ealing sent such an incomprehensible
letter to ISO residents that 40 of them wrote or telephoned to complain and ask for
clarification. Many were upset and frightened that the council was planning to imprison
them if they didn’t fill in the accompanying form. In fact, the letter meant nothing of the
sort, and the council had to send another letter to explain.
B
Plain legal English can be used as a marketing tactic. Provincial Insurance issued their
plain English Home Cover policy in 1983 and sold it heavily as such. In the first 18
months, its sales rocketed, drawing in about an extra £1.5 million of business. Recently,
the Eagle Star Group launched a plain English policy to a chorus of congratulatory letters
from policyholders. People, it seems, prefer to buy a policy they can understand.
C
Two kinds of instructions give us a lot of concern – medical labels and do-it-yourself
products. With medical labels, there is a serious gap between what the professionals
think is clear and what is really clear to patients. A survey by pharmacists Raynor and
Sillito found that 31% of patients misunderstood the instruction on eye drops ‘To be
instilled’, while 33% misunderstood ‘Use sparingly’. The instruction ‘Take two tablets 4
Trang 2
Passage 1 Plain English Campaign
2
hourly’ is so prone to misunderstanding (for example, as 8 tablets an hour) that we think
it should be banned. Unclear instructions on do-it-yourself products cause expense and
frustration to customers. Writing the necessary instructions for these products is usually
entrusted to someone who knows the product inside out, yet the best qualification for
writing instructions is ignorance. The writer is then like a first-time user, discovering
how to use the product in a step-by-step way. Instructions never seem to be tested with
first-time users before being issued. So vital steps are missed out or components are
mislabeled or not labelled at all. For example, the instructions for assembling a sliding
door gear say: ‘The pendant bolt centres are fixed and should be at an equal distance
from the centre of the door.’ This neglects to explain who should do the fixing and how
the bolt centres will get into the correct position. By using an imperative and an active
verb the instruction becomes much clearer: ‘Make sure you fix the centres of the
pendant bolts at an equal distance from the centre of the door.’
D
Effectively, the Plain English movement in the US began with President Jimmy Carter’s
Executive Order 12044 of 23 March 1978, that required regulations to be written in
plain language. There were earlier government efforts to inform consumers about their
rights and obligations, such as the Truth in Lending Act (1969) and the Fair Credit Billing
Act (1975), which emphasized a body of information that consumers need in simple
language. But President Carter’s executive order gave the prestige and force of a
president to the movement. All over the country isolated revolts or efforts against
legalistic gobbledygook at the federal, state and corporate levels seemed to grow into a
small revolution. These efforts and advances between the years 1978 and 1985 are
described in the panel ‘The Plain English Scorecard’.
E
The Bastille has not fallen yet. The forces of resistance are strong, as one can see from
the case of Pennsylvania as cited in the Scorecard. In addition, President Ronald
Reagan’s executive order of 19 February 1981, revoking President Carter’s earlier
executive order, has definitely slowed the pace of plain English legislation in the United
States. There are there main objections to the idea of plain English. They are given
below, with the campaign’s answer to them:
F
The statute would cause unending litigation and clog the courts. Simply not true in all
the ten states with plain English laws for consumer contracts and the 34 states with laws
or regulations for insurance policies. Since 1978 when plain English law went into effect
Trang 3
Passage 1 Plain English Campaign
3
in New York there have been only four litigations and only two decisions. Massachusetts
had zero cases. The cost of compliance would be enormous. Translation of legal
contracts into non-legal everyday language would be a waster of time and money. The
experience of several corporations has proved that the cost of compliance is often
outweighed by solid benefits and litigation savings. Citibank of New York made history in
1975 by introducing a simplified promissory note and afterwards simplified all their
forms. Citibank counsel Carl Falsenfield says: ‘We have lost no money and there has
been no litigation as a result of simplification.’ The cost-effectiveness of clarity is
demonstrable. A satisfied customer more readily signs on the bottom line and thus
contributes to the corporation’s bottom line. Some documents simply can’t be
simplified. The only legal language that has been tested for centuries in the courts is
precise enough to deal with a mortgage, a deed, a lease, or an insurance policy. Here,
too, the experience of several corporations and insurance companies has proved that
contracts and policies can be made more understandable without sacrificing legal
effectiveness.
G
What does the future hold for the Plain English movement? Today, American consumers
are buffeted by an assortment of pressures. Never before have consumers had as many
choices in areas like financial services, travel, telephone services, and supermarket
products. There are about 300 long-distance phone companies in the US. Not long ago,
the average supermarket carried 9,000 items; today, it carries 22,000. More
importantly, this expansion of options – according to a recent report – is faced by a
staggering 30 million Americans lacking the reading skills to handle the minimal
demands of daily living. The consumer’s need, therefore, for information expressed in
plain English is more critical than ever.
H
What is needed today is not a brake on the movement’s momentum but another push
toward plain English contracts from consumers. I still hear plain English on the TV and in
the streets, and read plain English in popular magazines and best-sellers, but not yet in
many functional documents. Despite some victories, the was against gobbledygook is
not over yet. We do well to remember, the warning of Chrissie Maher, organizer of Plain
English Campaign in the UK: ‘People are not just injured when medical labels are written
in gobbledygook – they die. Drivers are not just hurt when their medicines don’t tell them
they could fall asleep at the wheel – they are killed.’
Trang 4
Passage 1 Plain English Campaign
4
Questions 1-6
Do the following statements agree with the information given in Reading Passage 1?
In boxes 1-6 on your answer sheet, write
TRUE if the statement is true
FALSE if the statement is false
NOT GIVEN if the information is not given in the passage
1 In marketing area, the spread of Plain English can generate economic benefit.
2 Because doctors tend to use jargon when they talk with patients, thereafter many
patients usually get confused with medicine dose.
3 After successive election over U.S president Jimmy Carter, the effect of Plain English
Campaign is less distinctive than that of the previous one.
4 The Plain English campaigner has a problem of talking with the officials.
5 Work check is made regularly by the judge in the court scenario.
6 Compared with the situation of the past, consumers are now facing less intensity of
label reading pressure in a supermarket in America.
Questions 7-14
Complete the following summary of the paragraphs of Reading Passage.
Using NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS from the Reading Passage for each answer.
Write your answers in boxes 7-14 on your answer sheet.
Campaigners experienced a council renting document full of strange 7……………………… of
housing in terms of an Act. They are anxious in some other field, for instance, when
reading a label of medicine, there was an obvious 8……………………… for patients.
Another notable field was on 9………………………… products, it not only additionally cost
buyers but caused 10………………………, thus writer should regard himself as a
11…………………….. However, oppositions against the Plain English Campaign under
certain circumstances, e.g. 12……………………... language had been embellished as an
accurate language used in the 13……………………… The author suggested that nowadays
new compelling force is needed from 14……………………….
Trang 5
Passage 1 Plain English Campaign
5
ANSWER
1. TRUE
2. NOT GIVEN
3. TRUE
4. NOT GIVEN
5. NOT GIVEN
6. FALSE
7. jargon and waffle
8. Gap
9. do-it-yourself
10. frustration
11. first-time user
12. legal
13. courts
14. customers/ consumers
Hiển thị 5 trang đầu. Tải tài liệu để xem đầy đủ.
Bình luận (0)
Chưa có bình luận nào. Hãy là người đầu tiên!