Trang 1
Passage 1 Ants Could Teach Ants
1
SECTION 1
READING PASSAGE 1
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 1-13 which are based on Reading
Passage 1 below.
Ants Could Teach Ants
A
The ants are tiny and usually nest between rocks on the south coast of England.
Transformed into research subjects at the University of Bristol, they raced along a
tabletop foraging for food – and then, remarkably, returned to guide others. Time and
again, followers trailed behind leaders, darting this way and that along the route,
presumably to memorise landmarks. Once a follower got its bearings, it tapped the
leader with its antennae, prompting the lesson to literally proceed to the next step. The
ants were only looking for food, but the researchers said the careful way the leaders led
followers – thereby turning them into leaders in their own right – marked the
Temnothorax Albipennis ant as the very first example of a non-human animal exhibiting
teaching behaviour.
B
“Tandem running is an example of teaching, to our knowledge the first in a non-human
animal, that involves bidirectional feedback between teacher and pupil,” remarks Nigel
Franks, professor of animal behaviour and ecology, whose paper on the ant educators
was published last week in the journal Nature.
C
No sooner was the paper published, of course, than another educator questioned it.
Marc Hauser, a psychologist and biologist and one of the scientists who came up with
the definition of teaching, said it was unclear whether the ants had learned a new skill
or merely acquired new information.
D
Later, Franks took a further study and found that there were even races between
leaders. With the guidance of leaders, ants could find food faster. But the help comes at
a cost for the leader, who normally would have reached the food about four times faster
if not hampered by a follower. This means the hypothesis that the leaders deliberately
Trang 2
Passage 1 Ants Could Teach Ants
2
slowed down in order to pass the skills on to the followers seems potentially valid. His
ideas were advocated by the students who carried out the video project with him.
E
Opposing views still arose, however, Hauser noted that mere communication of
information is commonplace in the animal world. Consider a species, for example, that
uses alarm calls to warn fellow members about the presence of a predator. Sounding
the alarm can be costly, because the animal may draw the attention of the predator to
itself. But it allows others to flee to safety. “Would you call this teaching?” wrote
Hauser. “The caller incurs a cost. The naïve animals gain a benefit and new knowledge
that better enables them to learn about the predator’s location than if the caller had not
called. This happens throughout the animal kingdom, but we don’t call it teaching, even
though it is clearly a transfer of information.”
F
Tim Caro, a zoologist, presented two cases of animal communication. He found that
cheetah mothers that take their cubs along on hunts gradually allow their cubs to do
more of the hunting – going, for example, from killing a gazelle and allowing young cubs
to eat to merely tripping the gazelle and letting the cubs finish it off. At one level, such
behaviour might be called teaching – except the mother was not really teaching the
cubs to hunt but merely facilitating various stages of learning. In another instance, birds
watching other birds using a stick to locate food such as insects and so on, are observed
to do the same thing themselves while finding food later.
G
Psychologists study animal behaviour in part to understand the evolutionary roots of
human behaviour, Hauser said. The challenge in understanding whether other animals
truly teach one another, he added, is that human teaching involves a “theory of mind”
teachers are aware that students don’t know something. He questioned whether
Franks’s leader ants really knew that the follower ants were ignorant. Could they simply
have been following an instinctive rule to proceed when the followers tapped them on
the legs or abdomen? And did leaders that led the way to food – only to find that it had
been removed by the experimenter – incur the wrath of followers? That, Hauser said,
would suggest that the follower ant actually knew the leader was more knowledgeable
and not merely following an instinctive routine itself.
Trang 3
Passage 1 Ants Could Teach Ants
3
H
The controversy went on, and for a good reason. The occurrence of teaching in ants, if
proven to be true, indicates that teaching can evolve in animals with tiny brains. It is
probably the value of information in social animals that determines when teaching will
evolve, rather than the constraints of brain size.
I
Bennett Galef Jr., a psychologist who studies animal behaviour and social learning at
McMaster University in Canada, maintained that ants were unlikely to have a “theory of
mind” – meaning that leaders and followers may well have been following instinctive
routines that were not based on an understanding of what was happening in another
ant’s brain. He warned that scientists may be barking up the wrong tree when they look
not only for examples of humanlike behaviour among other animals but humanlike
thinking that underlies such behaviour among other animals but humanlike thinking that
underlies such behaviour. Animals may behave in ways similar to humans without a
similar cognitive system, he said, so the behaviour is not necessarily a good guide into
how humans came to think the way they do.
Questions 1-5
Look at the following statements (Questions 1-5) and the list of people in the box below.
Match each statement with the correct person, A, B, C or D.
Write the correct letter, A, B, C or D, in boxes 1-5 on your answer sheet.
NB You may use any letter more than once.
1 Animals could use objects to locate food.
2 Ants show two-way, interactive teaching behaviours.
3 It is risky to say ants can teach other ants like human beings do.
4 Ant leadership makes finding food faster.
5 Communication between ants is not entirely teaching.
Trang 4
Passage 1 Ants Could Teach Ants
4
List of People
A Nigel Franks
B Marc Hauser
C Tim Caro
D Bennett Galef Jr.
Questions 6-9
Choose FOUR letters, A-H.
Write your answers in boxes 6-9 on your answer sheet.
Which FOUR of the following behaviours of animals are mentioned in the passage?
A touch each other with antenna
B alert others when there is a danger
C escape from predators
D protect the young
E hunt food for the young
F fight with each other
G use tools like twigs
H feed on a variety of foods
Trang 5
Passage 1 Ants Could Teach Ants
5
Questions 9-13
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in Reading Passage 1?
In boxes 10-13 on your answer sheet, write
YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer
NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer
NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this
10 Ants’ tandem running involves only one-way communication.
11 Franks’s theory got many supporters immediately after publicity.
12 Ants’ teaching behaviour is the same as that of human.
13 Cheetah share hunting gains to younger ones.
Trang 6
Passage 1 Ants Could Teach Ants
6
ANSWER
1. C
2. A
3. D
4. A
5. B
6. A
7. B
8. E
9. G
10. NO
11. NOT GIVEN
12. NOT GIVEN
13. YES
Hiển thị 6 trang đầu. Tải tài liệu để xem đầy đủ.
Bình luận (0)
Chưa có bình luận nào. Hãy là người đầu tiên!