Trang 1
Passage 2 Mammoth kill 2
1
SECTION 2
READING PASSAGE 2
You should spend about 20 minutes on Question 14-26 which are based on Reading Passage 2
below.
Mammoth kill 2
Mammoth is any species of the extinct genus Mammuthus, proboscideans commonly equipped
with long, curved tusks and, in northern species, a covering of long hair. They lived from the
Pliocene epoch from around 5 million years ago, into the Holocene at about 4,500 years ago
and were members of the family Elephantidae, which contains, along with mammoths, the two
genera of modern elephants and their ancestors.
A
Like their modern relatives, mammoths were quite large. The largest known species reached
heights in the region of 4 m at the shoulder and weights up to 8 tonnes, while exceptionally
large males may have exceeded 12 tonnes. However, most species of mammoth were only
about as large as a modern Asian elephant. Both sexes bore tusks. A first, small set appeared at
about the age of six months and these were replaced at about 18 months by the permanent
set. Growth of the permanent set was at a rate of about 1 to 6 inches per year. Based on
studies of their close relatives, the modern elephants, mammoths probably had a gestation
period of 22 months, resulting in a single calf being born. Their social structure was probably
the same as that of African and Asian elephants, with females living in herds headed by a
matriarch, whilst bulls lived solitary lives or formed loose groups after sexual maturity.
B
MEXICO CITY – Although it’s hard to imagine in this age of urban sprawl and automobiles, North
America once belonged to mammoths, camels, ground sloths as large as cows, bear-size
beavers and other formidable beasts. Some 11,000 years ago, however, these large bodied
mammals and others – about 70 species in all – disappeared. Their demise coincided roughly
with the arrival of humans in the New World and dramatic climatic change – factors that have
inspired several theories about the die-off. Yet despite decades of scientific investigation, the
exact cause remains a mystery. Now new findings offer support to one of these controversial
hypotheses: that human hunting drove this megafaunal menagerie to extinction. The overkill
model emerged in the 1960s, when it was put forth by Paul S. Martin of the University of
Arizona. Since then, critics have charged that no evidence exists to support the idea that the
first Americans hunted to the extent necessary to cause these extinctions. But at the annual
meeting of the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology in Mexico City last October, paleoecologist
John Alroy of the University of California at Santa Barbara argued that, in fact, hunting- driven
Trang 2
Passage 2 Mammoth kill 2
2
extinction is not only plausible, it was unavoidable. He has determined, using a computer
simulation, that even a very modest amount of hunting would have wiped these animals out.
C
Assuming an initial human population of 100 people that grew no more than 2 percent
annually, Alroy determined that if each band of, say, 50 people killed 15 to 20 large mammals a
year, humans could have eliminated the animal populations within 1,000 years. Large mammals
in particular would have been vulnerable to the pressure because they have longer gestation
periods than smaller mammals and their young require extended care.
D
Not everyone agrees with Alroy’s assessment. For one, the results depend in part on
population-size estimates for the extinct animals – figures that are not necessarily reliable. But
a more specific criticism comes from mammalogist Ross D. E. MacPhee of the American
Museum of Natural History in New York City, who points out that the relevant archaeological
record contains barely a dozen examples of stone points embedded in mammoth bones (and
none, it should be noted, are known from other megafaunal remains) – hardly what one might
expect if hunting drove these animals to extinction. Furthermore, some of these species had
huge ranges – the giant Jefferson’s ground sloth, for example, lived as far north as the Yukon
and as far south as Mexico – which would have made slaughtering them in numbers sufficient
to cause their extinction rather implausible, he says.
E
Macphee agrees that humans most likely brought about these extinctions (as well as others
around the world that coincided with human arrival), but not directly. Rather he suggests that
people may have introduced hyperlethal disease, perhaps through their dogs or hitchhiking
vermin, which then spread wildly among the immunologically naive species of the New World.
As in the overkill model, populations of large mammals would have a harder time recovering.
Repeated outbreaks of a hyperdisease could thus quickly drive them to the point of no return.
So far MacPhee does not have empirical evidence for the hyperdisease hypotheses, and it
won’t be easy to come by: hyperlethal disease would kill far too quickly to leave its signature on
the bones themselves. But he hopes that analyses of tissue and DNA from the last mammoths
to perish will eventually reveal murderous microbes.
F
The third explanation for what brought on this North American extinction does not involve
human beings. Instead its proponents blame the loss on the water. The Pleistocene epoch
witnessed considerable climatic instability, explains paleontologist Russell W. Graham of the
Denver Museum of Nature and Science. As a result, certain habitats disappeared, and species
that had once formed communities split apart. For some animals, this change brought
opportunity. For much of the megafauna, however, the increasingly homogeneous
Trang 3
Passage 2 Mammoth kill 2
3
environment left them with shrinking geographical ranges – a death sentence for large animals,
which need large ranges. Although these creatures managed to maintain viable populations
through most of the Pleistocene, the final major fluctuation – the so-called Younger Dryas event
– pushed them over the edge, Graham says. For his part, Alroy is convinced that human hunters
demolished the titans of the Ice Age. The overkill model explains everything the disease and
climate scenarios explain, he asserts, and makes accurate predictions about which species
would eventually go extinct. “Personally, I’m a vegetarian,” he remarks, “and I find all of this
kind of gross – but believable.”
Questions 14-20
Complete the following summary of the paragraphs of Reading Passage
Using NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS from the Reading Passage for each answer.
Write your answers in boxes 14-20 on your answer sheet.
The reason why dad big size mammals become extinct 11,000 years ago is under hot debate.
First explanation is that 14 …………………… of human made it happen. This so called
15………………….. began from 1960s suggested by an expert, who however received criticism of
lack of further information. Another assumption promoted by MacPhee is that deadly
16…………………….. from human causes their demises. However his hypothesis required more
17…………………….. to testify its validity. Graham proposed a third hypothesis that
18…………………….. in Pleistocene epoch drove some species disappear, reduced
19……………………… posed a dangerous signal to these giants, and 20…………………… finally wiped
them out.
Trang 4
Passage 2 Mammoth kill 2
4
Questions 21-26
Use the information in the passage to match the people (listed A-C) with opinions or deeds
below.
Write the appropriate letters A-C in boxes 21-26 on your answer sheet.
NB You may use any letter more than once
A John Alroy
B Ross D. E. MacPhee
C Russell W. Graham
21 Human hunting well explained which species would finally disappear.
22 Further grounded proof needed to explain human’s indirect impact on mammals.
23 Over hunting situation has caused die-out of large mammals.
24 Illness rather than hunting caused extensive extinction.
25 Double raised through the study of several fossil records.
26 Climate shift is the main reason of extinction.
Trang 5
Passage 2 Mammoth kill 2
5
ANSWER
14. hunting
15. overkill model
16. disease/hyperdisease
17. empirical evidence
18. climatic instability
19. geographical ranges
20. Younger Dryas event
21. A
22. B
23. A
24. B
25. B
26. C
Hiển thị 5 trang đầu. Tải tài liệu để xem đầy đủ.
Bình luận (0)
Chưa có bình luận nào. Hãy là người đầu tiên!